The application of Chinese medicine theory is materialist dialectics, which applies the dialectical philosophy theory of unity of opposites of Yin and Yang and Five Elements to clinical syndrome differentiation and treatment, taking its essence and discarding its dross. Western medicine uses scientific and technological means to diagnose and treat. The two are different and cannot be compared. We should not have complete doubts about classics and ancient books, but should look at them from a philosophical dialectical point of view.
Classical ancient books are natural laws discovered by ancient sages and objective data accumulated. The ancients didn't make it up. Why doubt it? But learning Chinese medicine is not easy, it is quite detailed. If you are interested in fame and fortune, don't study it. An old Chinese doctor said, "Benevolent people are kind-hearted". Do you understand?
There is no point in reading a dead book. Only by reading words without words can you learn something real. This is a question of understanding, that is, people often say that IQ can only be verified. That certificate means nothing to clinical treatment, it's just a decoration. How many medical graduates can become masters of traditional Chinese medicine after taking the Shanghai Stock Exchange exam? On the contrary, most of the masters are people without certificates.
Of course not. There are three reasons.
1. As the oldest medical skill in China, Chinese medicine respects nature and conforms to human nature, so its value can last for thousands of years. The essence of this is not easily grasped and realized by ordinary people.
Thousands of years ago, human primitive environment, pure humanity, simple life, natural ingredients, instinctive way of life, pure thinking logic and concise communication and expression were all incompatible with today's prosperity, complexity and technology. That is the "pure" life called "pure" human beings. This disease is also a "natural" disease without modern "civilization" at this moment.
Therefore, the classics of ancient books left by doctors at that time are the treasures that can best reflect the integration of human instinct and natural laws.
We can't understand it, we can question it, we can give it some leisure, but we don't abandon it or doubt it, because no one knows what the author experienced thousands of years ago, and no one knows what wisdom was hidden in the simple words at that time.
Third, the times have changed, the environment has changed, people's living habits have changed, the diet structure has changed, the working methods have changed, and the medical conditions have changed ... This is a good thing, but it does not mean that the function of internal organs has changed. On the contrary, I think we have more ways to hurt our internal organs.
I think it is necessary for us human beings to reflect, go back to the past, be simple, be simple, be quiet, be quiet, read more ancient books and classics, and learn more about the essence.
Western medicine is mainly to cut the gordian knot, either cure or die. Although Chinese medicine is slow to treat people, it is not as effective as western medicine. Some chronic diseases are difficult to eradicate with western medicine. Traditional Chinese medicine treats both the symptoms and root causes. Once cured, it is likely that it will not recur for life, so the combination of traditional Chinese medicine is the best scheme.
This is wrong .. m,
If you doubt the classics of traditional Chinese medicine, you must make the past serve the present, tell the facts and theoretical basis realistically, and let the facts prove the wrong examples that have existed for thousands of years. Can you do it? The "classic" will also be happy and gratified, indicating that the waves behind the Yangtze River push the waves before, and there are successors.
The key is whether you have the ability to doubt. Is your doubt right or wrong? In fact, in the thousands of years of Chinese medicine inheritance, countless people who are much smarter than you have tried countless times, and these people's attempts ended in worshipping Chinese medicine classics. Do you think you have enough ability to surpass the wisdom of predecessors, to subvert thousands of years and countless generations, and to successfully verify it on countless more people? Western doctors began to doubt and try to falsify Chinese medicine from the Qing Dynasty or even earlier, but failed every time. In the end, they had to study Chinese medicine every day and try to copy it, not far away, but closer, smallpox, you know? In the west, it went from the elbow to the cottage and eventually became vaccinia, with a difference of 1000 years. Can you say that the west has subverted or surpassed Chinese medicine? Look at the western medicine therapy of leukemia, bone marrow transplantation, isn't it from the essence of Chinese medicine, the theory of hematopoietic terminal to the cottage? Verify the classics of Chinese medicine and try our own way, but the west has still failed, and the rejection can never be solved. The treatment of leukemia by Chinese medicine is radical, so don't worry about rejection. What kind of extraordinary intelligence and ability do you think you have to question TCM classics? By western stupid questions? Look at this COVID-19 epidemic. Is there even a country in the west with an answer? Chinese medicine has been ahead of the world for thousands of years, and no one can match it so far. What do you think your query results will be?