Contradiction? No contradiction: this poem uses two different standards-body and spirit. For example, Lei Feng, although people have been dead for many years, his spirit is still alive.
There is a saying in Chinese medicine-the body is yin and yang: the liver belongs to the viscera and yin; The liver is used to disperse qi and yang.
Anatomy is about the position of viscera; The left liver and right lung in traditional Chinese medicine are related to the function of viscera. Both sides are right-two different standards. .
That's all. It's that simple.
Zhang Xichun's medical enthusiasm and learning from the west have a special discussion on this. If you are interested, you can check Baidu.
The "left liver and right lung" often mentioned by folk Chinese medicine is different from the anatomical results. What's going on here?
Anatomically speaking, the liver is indeed on the right side, in the right rib, and this Chinese medicine is also clear. However, it is necessary to determine whether it is liver disease in the treatment of diseases, and it is necessary to determine it from the pulse when diagnosing. Although the liver is on the right, the pulse is on the left.
People are divided into six veins, and the order of the left three parts is heart, liver and kidney. The right side is divided into lung, spleen and life gate, which is actually the right kidney. Why is it called Mingmen? This is the left governing qi and the right governing blood. If it is a woman's right kidney, it is the most important, so it is called Ming Men. Blood deficiency, blood deficiency, or the basic pulse of pregnancy is at the door of life. Because of this, the left liver and right lung, that is, the meridians of the human body are arranged in this way. Traditional Chinese medicine has the saying that the liver is the main reinforcement and the kidney is the main bone. Because of this, liver and kidney are brothers, so beginners must work hard on pulse diagnosis.
"Left liver and right lung" comes from Huangdi Neijing: left liver and right lung, upper heart and lower kidney, spleen in the middle. Describe the qi circulation of the internal organs, that is, explain the relationship between the internal organs.
The understanding of human body in TCM theory is based on the philosophy of Yin-Yang and Five Elements, and the relationship between zang-fu organs is based on philosophy.
Anatomy of the position of the liver and lung must exist in ancient medicine in China. At that time, there were no psychological and legal obstacles to dissecting a dead slave, and the improvement of medical level was also a promoting factor. At that time, values were more important than skills, and the works were willing to ponder the operational logic behind them; It is in line with the characteristics of the times to think about things including Chinese medicine with the theory of Yin-Yang and Five Elements, Taoism and Yijing.
Physiologically, the liver is on the right side of the human body, and the right hypochondriac pain is caused by liver problems. It is also helpful to add some lung drugs (lung metal) while adding liver drugs. Folk doctors may remember that some drugs for treating lung are really effective for hypochondriasis. Similarly, left hypochondriac pain often starts from the spleen (such as splenomegaly) and belongs to the soil; Auxiliary use of some drugs for treating liver (wood) is also helpful for spleen pain. Liver, left lung and right lung may have such different understandings here. According to folk Chinese medicine, it may be like this. There is a misunderstanding, and medical theory works.
If you can't even figure out the location of the internal organs, what can you call a doctor? It can be seen that the left liver and right lung are not referring to the position of organs, so don't take them out of context.
Chinese medicine is extensive and profound, which not only studies the internal organs, but also clearly knows which meridian enters which organ.
In the face of Chinese medicine, we must have awe. We have cured a nation for thousands of years, while other ancient civilizations have disappeared. The only reason is the greatness of Chinese medicine. But when cultural scholars talk about this matter, they generally say that Chinese civilization is inclusive, open and inclusive ... and never talk about the role of Chinese medicine.
Foreigners belittle Chinese medicine, and we in China should not. We should not only admit it, but also carry it forward and get back some inventions belonging to Chinese medicine, such as vaccines, antibiotics, anesthetics and surgery ... all these inventions or discoveries should belong to Chinese medicine.
The "left liver and right lung" often mentioned by folk Chinese medicine is definitely inconsistent with the anatomical results. 1. The theory of "left liver and right lung" in TCM refers to the position in pulse diagnosis, that is, the left-hand pulse gate is the "heart, liver and kidney" channel, and the right-hand pulse gate is the "lung, spleen and stomach" channel. Chinese medicine inquires about the condition through pulse diagnosis, so as to know which viscera or organs of the human body are treated after illness. Second, the achievements of human anatomy mainly refer to.
The ancients said: What does the left liver and right lung mean?
Chinese medicine practitioners don't know why, and it's no use talking nonsense.
A little knowledge and poor interpretation of traditional Chinese medicine powder really stems from incomplete reading and intentional ignorance.
Ancient Chinese medicine was mainly functional. However, human diseases often take dysfunction as the first priority, and develop from functional lesions to organic lesions. The ancients used to be shorter than their bodies. However, physical fitness is the strength of western medicine and modern science. That's understandable.
The ancients' left liver and right lung refers to the theory that liver qi rises to the left, lung qi falls to the right, rises and falls back and forth, and circulates endlessly, which comes from the theory of yin and yang, the integration of heaven and earth, and so on. It does not refer to the entity of the liver and lungs of the human body.
The staff sergeant heard the word and tried to do it. The corporal laughed at the word, but it wasn't enough.
The things of the ancients are reserved for people who have a destiny. Don't be forced, go back to your home and find your mother.
Buddhism is boundless and difficult to cross. So is Li Siyi.
The left liver and right lung mentioned in Huangdi Neijing are obviously inconsistent with modern anatomy. In the human body, it is obviously the liver on the right!
So is the Yellow Emperor wrong? But on the other hand, can the Yellow Emperor, as a doctor, make such a low-level mistake? The wise ancients could not know where the human liver was! If you think the Yellow Emperor is so clever and so low-level, then you may be too self-righteous! .
The question is what does the left liver and right lung in Neijing mean? It may not mean that the liver is on the right side of the body, but something else. What mysteries about medical ethics are hidden in the human body?
As far as modern medical knowledge is concerned, there is something "in the opposite direction". It's the left brain tube, the right brain tube, the left brain tube!
In other words, the functions of some organs in the human body may be opposite to their positions. From this point of view, the left liver and right lung in Neijing does not refer to the position of liver and lung, but refers to the position of some function or meridian qi movement.
It is ok to boldly question questions you don't understand, but you should also think carefully in many aspects, and don't be too self-righteous and blindly arrogant.
This sentence is really good without common sense. Generally speaking, this statement refers to an expression of qi movement, not anatomical parts. No matter how stupid the ancients were, they knew that the lungs were in the chest and the liver was in the right upper abdomen. This is completely unmistakable.
Chinese medicine says it rises left and falls right. The function of the liver is ascending. Moreover, the function of the lung has a healthy function, which is the origin of the saying that the left liver and the right lung.
Attacking Chinese medicine with this can only show ignorance and nothing else. If you want to hit something, at least understand it. I only talk nonsense on the internet, and I don't want to know anything at all. At most, I am a social scum who has nothing to do on the Internet.
From the Book of Changes to the Eight Diagrams, the left is also wood, the right is also gold, the liver is wood, and the lungs are gold, so the left liver is gold. The realm in Huangdi Neijing and the spatial position in the interpretation theory are not the same, but two completely different theoretical systems.
All positions have references. For example, I'm from Hunan, of course I'm from the south, but Cantonese people say I'm from the north, and they're right. According to the modern anatomical position, the liver is on the right and the lung is in the chest above the abdominal cavity. But if you change the reference, I face you face to face, and your liver is on the left side of my sight; If you lie in front of me with your feet on the left, your lungs will be on the right side of my sight. Of course, the theory of Neijing in Chinese medicine originated from Yijing, the so-called Yi. I ching gossip says left dragon right, white tiger right. Qinglong is in the east, the five elements belong to wood, and the five internal organs are the liver; The white tiger is in the west, the five elements belong to gold, and the five internal organs are the lungs. So the left liver and right lung correspond to the left dragon and the right white tiger. Without five lines of gossip's knowledge of Chinese studies, there will be misunderstandings. Some people laugh at the mistake of "left liver and right lung" in traditional Chinese medicine. In fact, we should review our knowledge first.