1643, after Li Zicheng conquered Ann, Zhu Cunshu, the king of Qin, chose to surrender, and was named "all generals" by Li Zicheng to join the army and stay in Beijing. At the gates of Beijing, Zhu Cunshu also persuaded the defenders of the Li Zicheng Rebel Army to surrender. Ming History Volume IV: No children, and the friendship with my brother was inherited by Wang Ziyang. You, son, save the pivot heir. Li Zicheng broke the peace, saved the thief, gave the general a fake award, and my concubine Liu died.
It can be seen that this record clearly points out that after the death of Zhu Yijun, the king of Ming Dynasty, Zhu Cunshu, the eldest son of Shu, attacked Jue and surrendered to Li Zicheng. Later, he followed Li Zicheng's crusade against Wu Sangui, and Li Zicheng's army killed him after losing the Battle of One Stone. For more than 300 years, people have been convinced of this history, but archaeological discoveries have completely overturned the records of Ming history. 1978, in the southern suburbs of Xi 'an, Shaanxi, archaeologists excavated an ancient tomb of the Ming Dynasty. According to the epitaph, the owner of the tomb is Zhu Cunshu.
This is very strange. After Zhu Cunshu was brought to Beijing by Li Zicheng, why was he buried in Xi 'an? In that war-torn era, it was almost impossible to transport Zhu Cunshu's remains from Beijing to Xi. Did Zhu Cunshu really not die in Beijing, but fled back to Xi 'an? According to the unearthed Tomb of the Prince and Concubine Zhang, the record of Ming history is nonsense, because Zhu Cunshu can never surrender to Li Zicheng.