Just say a TV series, you say it's good, I say it's not good, and he says it's ok. This is that everyone has a different attitude and aesthetic when watching it. So is calligraphy. Especially in today's calligraphy circle, most of the writers mean to blow each other "sticks", so you say my sticks and I say yours, that's all? Flatter each other? Get up. The popularity will increase. Hey.
Let me talk about your topic first, whether it is brush calligraphy or hard pen calligraphy, in fact, the criteria for judging the pros and cons are the same.
My opinion:
First, the calligraphy (competition) judges should have a high personal quality. Don't judge a work by personal likes and dislikes.
Secondly, the ancient law is not muddy. If we blindly follow some ancient writing styles, society will not progress. It depends on whether the work follows the ancient law and whether it can be innovated on the basis of the ancient law.
Third, whether the content of the work is integrated with the performance of calligraphy. (For example, Yue Fei's "Man Jiang Hong" is only written in rich colors (almost "ink pig"), which may not express Yue Fei's "grief and indignation"; Dry and vigorous writing may not reveal Yue Fei's "grief and indignation" passion. The style of writing is too soft, and it smells like Jia Lian's powder.
Fourth, we should read between the lines to figure out the author's skill. As for punctuation, the shelf structure of each word and the layout of the whole article should also be considered whether it is prominent or not.
Fifthly, compare and review similar articles (such as banners, such as bucket squares) and release books (official scripts, seal scripts, etc.). ) put them together for horizontal comparison.
Sixth, write your own poems with high marks. It's always Tang poetry and Song poetry. It's going to cool down.
Seventh, stamping and mounting are second.
The above is my family's view, and I hope it can be a topic of discussion.