First of all, Mr. Lu Xun was born in 188 1 and died in 1936. In fact, this period is not far from us today, and it is relatively easy to preserve documents and research historical materials. However, there is no record in historical materials that Mr. Lu Xun ever wrote a poem about a sick begonia and sent it to Osamu Dazai Jun, but this article has been circulated on the Internet. Obviously,
Secondly, the years of Lu Xun's death are 1936, 10, 19. At this time, what kind of person is Osamu Dazai, the hero in Talking about Begonia Poems? Osamu Dazai was treated in hospital for poisoning, while Osamu Dazai was only in his early twenties. A China scholar in his fifties is far from a Japanese writer when he was young. Besides, when Lu Xun was alive, Osamu Dazai was just a writer who was not well-known in Japan. How do two people establish a friendly relationship?
Finally, some poems and sentences in this article were actually written by Mr. Lu Xun. So some people think that the author of this article is Lu Xun. In this article, many experiences, images and techniques are very similar to Lu Xun's Miscellaneous Talks after Illness. So this article is likely to be imitated by others.