Is the teaching of tortoise and rabbit writing effective? Which is better than a river elephant?

To compare which is better, let's first look at the similarities and differences between the two:

Tortoise and rabbit write, and the pattern is calligrapher? +? The ordinary teacher corrects homework, and the course lecturer is Xie Tingting, the calligrapher of China Hard Pen Calligraphy Association and the tutor of the National Children's Calligraphy and Hard Pen Calligraphy Competition. The form of class is online recording and broadcasting of one-on-one comments by teachers, divided into words, one word in each class. However, in the curriculum, it comes in the order of new words in the new Chinese textbook. This is actually quite practical. Students can kill two birds with one stone by practicing writing and learning new words after class. If you punch in, you will also practice in class that day. There is an extra column on their exercise paper to consolidate the last part of the exercise. The exercise content is uploaded and commented by a special calligraphy teacher.

River elephant, the protagonist is also a calligrapher? +? Ordinary teachers correct homework, and course lecturer Gong is a calligrapher of Zhejiang Hard Pen Calligraphy Association. For primary school students, this level is more than enough. The class form is divided into words, one word in each class. There are elementary, middle and advanced courses, and the course arrangement is from simple to difficult, but the relevance will be weaker. If you practice, students practice according to the class of the day, and then upload comments.

Personally, I think tortoise and rabbit are better in mode and teaching. First of all, it can be said that the synchronization of teaching materials is excellent. On the one hand, it is convenient for students to apply what they have learned, on the other hand, it also plays a certain counseling role. Secondly, in the class, Mr. Gong, the elephant in the river, has a strong accent, which is actually difficult for children to accept. At this point, Mr. Tortoise and Rabbit Xie's pronunciation is very clear and standard.

In addition, in the teaching of Chinese characters, the writing of tortoise and hare is the standard teaching of Chinese characters, while the teaching of calligraphy art is the form teaching. We all know that calligraphy is allowed to change the writing style of strokes to achieve the pursuit of aesthetic feeling, but it is very misleading for children, because irregular writing leads to typos, thus deducting points!