The first aspect, starting with poetry.
"Song of Gaixia" tells the story of Xiang Yu's impassioned and tragic feelings about his destiny when he was surrounded by Gaixia, besieged on all sides, and seeing his ambitions and ambitions about to be dashed, and the future of his beautiful horse and concubine was also uncertain.
Song of the Big Wind is a song written by Liu Bang after he defeated Ying Bu. He expressed his feelings of returning to his hometown after defeating the enemy, and also expressed his worries about whether he could defend the world.
As for the style of Chu, it is because Liu Bang's hometown has been occupied by Chu for a long time, and the language and customs of Chu have also influenced this place. Xiang Yu is a native of Chu, so it is normal to have Chu style in his poems.
So, it should be unintentional.
The second aspect, from the actual situation to analyze.
"Gaixia Song" is from Historical Records of Xiang Yu. It is recorded in the article: "Wang Xiang's army was under siege, and there were many vassals and soldiers in the Han army. At night, when I heard that the Han army was besieged on all sides, I was frightened and said, "Has Han gained Chu?" ? He Chu has so many people!' Wang Xiang gets up at night and drinks in his tent. If you have a beauty, you will always be lucky; Good horses are famous and often ride. Therefore, Wang Xiang was elegant and generous, and wrote a poem for himself:' If you pull out a mountain, you will be angry with the world, and if it is unfavorable, you will not die. What can I do without dying? What can I do if I am worried? "Songs count, beauty and it. Xiang Wang cried several times, and both sides cried, so he dared not look up. "
First of all, we know that Historical Records was written by Sima Qian, and Sima Qian's father, Sima Tan, also made an official order in the Han Dynasty. Their family specializes in making history. When Sima Qian was writing Historical Records, it was said that he traveled all over famous mountains and rivers, learned about people and old people at that time, collected information and wrote history books according to the ancestors' statements.
Therefore, the book Historical Records is actually a combination of historical facts and fiction, just like Xiang Yu's "The Surrounding of Gaixia". Sima Qian knew when and where Xiang Yu was surrounded by who led many people, and he might even know where Xiang Yu took many people to escape. However, after all, he is not a witness of this period of history, and he has never followed Xiang Yu, so how can he know the military account in a poem called Gaixia Song?
So I guess that "Gaixia Song" was not necessarily written by Xiang Yu himself, but was imagined by Sima Qian according to the situation and environment at that time. If so, what did Liu Can, the founding emperor of the Han Dynasty think of the articles written by Sima Qian during the reign of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty?
Therefore, Liu Bang's Song of the Wind is not intended to ridicule Xiang Yu.
Hope to adopt, welcome to exchange and discuss.