Comprehensive comments on thesis defense

Thesis defense comments are an important part of science and technology management work. There are still questions to be explored about the concepts, methods and systems of scientific paper evaluation. The following are comprehensive comments on thesis defenses, welcome to refer to them.

1. The structure of the full text is basically reasonable and scientific, the logical thinking is clear, the viewpoints are expressed accurately, the language is fluent, the argumentation method is reasonable, and the referenced literature materials meet the theme requirements. From the theme to the content, it meets the professional requirements. The connection between the parts and the parts is relatively close. However, individual quotations are not marked. There is not much content that is truly my own innovation. Some concepts are relatively vague. Overall, it meets the graduation thesis requirements.

2. The student has strong ability to consult literature and information, can collect information about the examination system comprehensively, can comprehensively apply knowledge of the examination system in the writing process, comprehensively analyze examination system problems, and has strong ability to comprehensively apply knowledge. .

3. The structure of the paper is complete, and each part basically conforms to the writing standards of _____ paper. The topic of the paper is very good and creative. In order to write this paper, the author did some research, especially Steinbeck's original works. It is not difficult to see from the author's citations of the original work that the author is quite familiar with the content of the original work. The language is also very sharp, the paper is clear and well-reasoned, the views are original, and have certain reference value. It is a good article.

4. Comments on the paper: Pass: The topic selection of the paper is in line with the professional training objectives and can basically achieve the comprehensive training objectives. The topic difficulty is relatively small and the workload is not large. Thesis topics are general. The student's ability to consult literature is poor, and he is unable to comprehensively collect information about the examination system. His ability to comprehensively apply the knowledge of the examination system in the writing process and comprehensively analyze the problems of the examination system is poor. The length of the article complies with the regulations of the college, but the content is not complete enough, there are certain problems in the hierarchical structure arrangement, the main points are not prominent enough, the logic is poor, and there is no personal opinion. The title of the article is biased, the argument is not prominent enough, and the discussion cannot closely focus on the topic. The language expression is poor, and the format meets the standard requirements; there is less information and its timeliness is poor; some content is similar to other people's results.

5. Comments on thesis? Excellent: Thesis topic selection is in line with professional training goals and can achieve comprehensive training goals. The topics are relatively difficult and the workload is heavy. The selected topic has high academic research (reference) value (great practical guidance significance). The student has strong ability to consult literature and materials, can comprehensively collect information about the examination system, can comprehensively use examination system knowledge in the writing process, comprehensively analyze examination system problems, and has strong ability to comprehensively apply knowledge. The length of the article fully complies with the regulations of the college, the content is complete, the hierarchical structure is scientifically arranged, the main points are prominent, the logical relationship is clear, and there are certain personal opinions. The title of the article is completely consistent, the argument is prominent, and the discussion is closely related to the theme. The language expression is fluent, and the format fully meets the standard requirements; it refers to a wealth of literature and materials, and is highly timely; there is no plagiarism.

6. The title of the article is consistent, the argument is prominent, and the discussion is closely related to the theme.

7. The thesis topic selection is in line with professional training goals and can achieve comprehensive training goals. The topics are difficult and the workload is large. The selected topic has academic research (reference) value (practical guidance significance).

8. The title of the article is biased, the argument is not prominent enough, and the discussion cannot closely focus on the topic.

9. The length of the article fully complies with the regulations of the college, the content is relatively complete, the hierarchical structure is scientifically arranged, the main points are prominent, and the logical relationship is clear, but it lacks personal insights.

10. The language expression is fluent, and the format fully meets the specification requirements; it refers to a wealth of literature and materials, and is highly timely; there is no plagiarism.

11. The language expression is fluent, and the format fully meets the standard requirements; it refers to a relatively rich literature and is highly timely; no plagiarism has been found.

12. The thesis topic selection is in line with professional training objectives and can achieve comprehensive training objectives. The topics are of certain difficulty and the workload is average. The selected topic has academic research (reference) value (practical guidance significance).

13. The student has average ability to consult literature and can collect information about the examination system. In the writing process, he can basically comprehensively apply the knowledge of the examination system, comprehensively analyze the problems of the examination system, and has average ability to comprehensively apply knowledge.

14. The topic selection is contemporary and realistic. The structure of the full text is reasonably arranged. The views expressed are basically accurate. The full text is written closely in line with the requirements of the administrative management profession, fully reflecting the characteristics of the administrative management profession. There is a lot of relevant information to consult. But the main shortcoming is that there are not many things of my own innovation. Generally speaking, it meets the graduation thesis requirements.

15. The topic of the thesis is meaningful. On the basis of absorbing the research results of the academic community, it has its own "experience" and puts forward its own opinions, which are reasonable. The argumentation point of view is correct, the material is relatively substantial, the narrative level is clear, and it has strong logic. The writing is smooth and smooth. The writing conforms to academic standards. In the future, we should further summarize our experience and compare music education models, so that we can teach music better. The thesis can be submitted on time, and after careful revision, it has met the requirements of undergraduate thesis.

16. The research content is realistic and operable. The topic is a hot social issue and the logical structure is rigorous.

The views are clearly expressed and the discussion is comprehensive. The language is plain, concise and easy to understand. In the process of argumentation, we can also better combine professional knowledge principles with practical problems. But the arguments are not enough. Generally speaking, it meets the graduation thesis requirements.

17. The student has poor ability to consult literature and cannot comprehensively collect information about the examination system. In the writing process, he comprehensively uses the knowledge of the examination system and has poor ability to comprehensively analyze the problems of the examination system.

18. The student has strong ability to consult literature and information, can comprehensively collect information about the examination system, can comprehensively apply knowledge of the examination system in the writing process, comprehensively analyze examination system problems, and has strong ability to comprehensively apply knowledge.

19. The length of the article complies with the regulations of the college, the content is not complete enough, there are certain problems in the hierarchical structure arrangement, the main points are not prominent enough, the logic is poor, and there is no personal opinion.

20. The language expression is average, and the format fully meets the standard requirements; certain literature and materials are referenced, and their timeliness is average; no obvious plagiarism is found.

21. The topic selected for this paper has strong application value. The literature materials are collected in detail, and the knowledge learned is used to solve the problem. The data obtained is reasonable, the conclusions are correct, and there are innovative insights. In addition, the format of the paper is correct, the writing is standardized, the organization is clear, and the language is fluent. In the future, we should further sum up experience and compare moral education models, so that moral education can work better. The thesis can be submitted on time, and after careful revision, it has met the requirements of undergraduate thesis.

22. The language expression is poor, and the format meets the standard requirements; there is less information and its timeliness is poor; some content is similar to other people's results.

23. The title of the article is completely consistent, the argument is prominent, and the discussion is closely related to the theme.

24. Thesis comments? Medium: Thesis topic selection is in line with professional training goals and can achieve comprehensive training goals. The topics are of certain difficulty and the workload is average. The selected topic has academic research (reference) value (practical guidance significance). The student's ability to consult literature and information is average, and he can collect information about the examination system. In the writing process, he can basically comprehensively apply the knowledge of the examination system, comprehensively analyze the problems of the examination system, and his ability to comprehensively apply knowledge is average. The length of the article fully complies with the regulations of the college, the content is basically complete, the hierarchical structure is generally arranged, and the main points are logical to a certain extent, but it lacks personal insights. The title of the article is basically consistent, the argument is more prominent, and the discussion can better serve the argument. The language expression is general, and the format fully meets the standard requirements; certain literature and materials are referenced, and their timeliness is average; there is no obvious plagiarism.

25. The thesis title is basically consistent with the content of the paper, the structure is complete, and the language is relatively fluent. Even in the first draft, there were not many serious grammatical or spelling errors, apart from overly detailed paragraphing. The author tries to find the connection between a certain character in his novel from the works of Leo Tolstoy and Cao Yu. Judging from the content, the author has a relatively good understanding of the original work and has collected relevant information. How to draw his own conclusions through analyzing the information is the purpose of writing a paper, and it is precisely on this point that the author has worked hard.

26. Thesis topic selection is in line with professional training goals and can achieve comprehensive training goals. The topics are relatively difficult and the workload is heavy. The selected topic has high academic research (reference) value (great practical guidance significance).

27. The length of the article fully complies with the regulations of the college, the content is basically complete, the hierarchical structure is generally arranged, the main points are logical to a certain extent, but it lacks personal insights.

28. The length of the article fully complies with the regulations of the college, the content is complete, the hierarchical structure is scientifically arranged, the main points are prominent, the logical relationship is clear, and there is a certain degree of personal opinion.

29. This article studies ____. It has strong practical value in dealing with accounting information distortion and provides a new basis. The author's thinking is clear, the discussion process is rigorous, the analysis is reasonable, and the results have strong practical application. The paper is written in a standardized manner and the sentences are fluent, meeting the school's various requirements for dissertations.

30. Comments on the thesis? Liang: The topic selection of the thesis is in line with the professional training objectives and can achieve the comprehensive training objectives. The topics are difficult and the workload is large. The selected topic has academic research (reference) value (practical guidance significance). This student has a strong ability to consult literature and information, can collect information about the examination system comprehensively, can comprehensively use examination system knowledge in the writing process, comprehensively analyze examination system problems, and has a strong ability to comprehensively apply knowledge. The length of the article fully complies with the regulations of the college, the content is relatively complete, the hierarchical structure is scientifically arranged, the main points are prominent, and the logical relationship is clear, but it lacks personal insights. The title of the article is consistent, the argument is prominent, and the discussion is closely related to the theme. The language expression is fluent, and the format fully complies with the standard requirements; it refers to a relatively rich literature and is highly timely; no plagiarism has been found.

Selected comprehensive comments for thesis defense

1. The topic is novel, closely combined with clinical practice, and reasonably designed. It is a research hotspot in this discipline, and the research work has certain theoretical and practical significance. value. The content of the paper is basically consistent with the title, with a complete structure, standardized format, clear hierarchy, well-organized, smooth and fluent language, and rich content. The collection of literature materials is rich and detailed, basically covering the main literature related to this subject, and it has a certain inductive effect on the development trend of this subject.

The data are sufficient, the discussion process is rigorous, the ideas are clear, the knowledge learned is comprehensively used to solve problems, the analysis methods are appropriately selected, and the results are credible. The paper is written seriously, the reasoning is logical, and the conclusions and suggestions are of practical significance. It is a master's thesis with high academic value.

2. From the defense, it can be seen that the student has a solid professional foundation in general, sufficient preparation, is very familiar with the content of the paper, can state the design ideas and processes concisely and clearly, can present the system fluently, and answers questions rationally. According to the data, the basic concepts are clear and the paper has certain innovations. I hope to continue to improve some of the words and symbols in the paper and strive to standardize their use.

3. ___’s master’s thesis “An Empirical Study on the Impact of Consumers’ Online Shopping Website Experience on Online Purchasing Intention” based on relevant literature research and current affairs dynamic analysis, studied the impact of website experience The topic selection has certain theoretical value and practical significance.

4. The literature cited in this paper is representative and scientific. The relevant Chinese and foreign literature materials are comprehensively analyzed and summarized, and the research background, research status and development prospects of ____ are mastered. The literature The review is rich and standardized.

5. In the ten-minute presentation, the student introduced the main points, content and structure of the paper, as well as the writing process of the paper. It was clearly organized, with no major mistakes in language, and responded to the teacher’s questions. Basically correct answers reflect a certain degree of professionalism. However, there is a slight problem in the design process, and the flow chart is not very complete. I hope it will be corrected in time.

6. ___’s thesis “Analysis and Research on the Data Model of College Undergraduate Major Setting Prediction System Based on Data Mining” was selected from the University Undergraduate Major Setting Prediction System Project entrusted by the Ministry of Education to Sun Yat-sen University . The research results of this paper have certain pilot significance for building a prediction system for undergraduate major settings in colleges and universities.

7. In the five-minute presentation, the student introduced the main content and structure of the paper, as well as the research conducted for it, showing that he had a certain understanding of the problem being studied. The video design is beautiful, but it does not meet professional requirements. It would be better if the implementation process was designed from a computer professional perspective.

8. The paper uses statistical analysis software to conduct factor analysis. The paper is rich in content, clear in structure, complete in structure, detailed in data collection, accurate in data, clear and powerful in argumentation, sufficient and reliable in arguments, and reliable in conclusions.

9. The student has relatively good professionalism, can answer the questions fluently, has a high accuracy rate, has a good understanding of the difficulties encountered in the implementation process, and has a good grasp of time. If he can use a relatively new operating environment It's relatively good to implement.

10. The thesis statement is clear, straight to the point, and goes directly to the topic. I can answer the teacher's questions fluently and have clear ideas. However, I cannot explain part of the code in the paper clearly and there are a few language errors. I hope to be more innovative in future research.

11. Combine mathematical knowledge with computer technology to deal with geological problems, have a thorough grasp of method principles, and have relatively good innovations in the paper. The results of fast Fourier and wavelet transform diagrams are well analyzed, the processing results are good, and the basic computer literacy is good. The main questions in the defense were answered accurately and in depth. It would be better if the transformation indicators in the paper are compared.

12. The student can explain the main content of the paper relatively fluently and clearly within the specified time, can appropriately answer questions related to the paper, has a humble attitude, and reflects a relatively solid computer foundation. It is recommended to express the image opening function in appropriate words and continue to improve and standardize the format of the paper.

13. The topic selection of this paper is reasonable, provides theoretical support for ____, and the research is of great significance.

14. The student fluently stated the purpose, theoretical and practical significance of writing the paper. The antique website design process is very standardized, but there is little connection between entities and concepts. The entire design should try to comply with computer aspects. Require.

15. This paper reflects the author’s solid theoretical foundation, systematic professional knowledge and good scientific research ability in this subject. Having met the requirements for a master's degree thesis, it is recommended to arrange a defense.

Comprehensive comments on excellent thesis defenses

1. During his studies, Zhao Jiayi worked hard, read extensively, had a solid professional foundation, and had theoretical analysis ability. This paper focuses on the poetry creation of Lin Huiyin, a female poet of the Crescent School who has received less attention, and focuses on analyzing the influence of British romantic poetry on Lin's poetry. It has theoretical and practical significance. The paper deeply explores the occurrence and manifestation of this influence from three aspects: life experience, aesthetic system, and art system. The point of view is clear and the argument is powerful. The interpretation of the paper is meticulous, the writing is delicate and friendly, and it is gentle and readable. The shortcoming is that the relationship between Lin Huiyin's changes in mood and creation under the impact of the times can be further expanded. Overall, I think this is a master's thesis that meets the requirements, and I agree to recommend this student to apply for thesis defense.

2. The student has strong ability to consult literature and materials, can comprehensively collect information about the examination system, can comprehensively apply knowledge of the examination system in the writing process, comprehensively analyze examination system problems, and has strong ability to comprehensively apply knowledge.

3. The thesis topic selection is in line with professional training goals and can achieve comprehensive training goals. The topics are relatively difficult and the workload is heavy.

The selected topic has high academic research (reference) value (great practical guidance significance).

4. The length of the article fully complies with the regulations of the college, the content is complete, the hierarchical structure is scientifically arranged, the main points are prominent, the logical relationship is clear, and there is a certain degree of personal opinion.

5. The length of the article fully complies with the regulations of the college, the content is basically complete, the hierarchical structure is generally arranged, the main points are logical to a certain extent, but it lacks personal insights.

6. The language expression is fluent, and the format fully meets the standard requirements; it refers to a relatively rich literature and is highly timely; no plagiarism has been found.

7. The student’s ability to consult literature is average, and he can collect information about the examination system. In the writing process, he can basically comprehensively apply the knowledge of the examination system, comprehensively analyze the problems of the examination system, and his ability to comprehensively apply knowledge is average.

8. The author’s work has good practical application value. The thesis is carefully written, rigorously structured and fluent, which reflects that the author has the ability to engage in scientific research. He agrees to defend his master’s thesis.

9. The title of the article is biased, the argument is not prominent enough, and the discussion cannot closely focus on the topic.

10. The student has a strong ability to consult literature and information, can collect information about the examination system comprehensively, can comprehensively apply knowledge of the examination system during the writing process, comprehensively analyze examination system problems, and has a strong ability to comprehensively apply knowledge. .

11. This topic is novel in topic selection, closely combined with clinical practice, and reasonably designed. It is a research hotspot in this discipline, and the research work has certain theoretical significance and practical value. The content of the paper is basically consistent with the title, with a complete structure, standardized format, clear hierarchy, well-organized, smooth and fluent language, and rich content. The collection of literature materials is rich and detailed, basically covering the main literature related to this subject, and it has a certain inductive effect on the development trend of this subject. The data are sufficient, the discussion process is rigorous, the ideas are clear, the knowledge learned is comprehensively used to solve problems, the analysis methods are appropriately selected, and the results are credible. The paper is written seriously, the reasoning is logical, and the conclusions and suggestions are of practical significance. It is a master's thesis with high academic value.

13. The language expression is average, and the format fully meets the standard requirements; certain literature and materials are referenced, and the timeliness is average; there is no obvious plagiarism.

14. It can be seen from the content of the paper that the author has rich information and discusses the existing problems in the current land expropriation compensation system and its operation. Then, a more feasible solution was put forward based on learning from relevant foreign legal systems, and ___ had certain new ideas.