Sometimes, poets of new poetry do innovate the style of poetry, but privately, they think that these two styles are not special forms.
The following are the views of some scholars. Basically, I agree with them. Those who are interested can read the full text. In addition, let me extract it for you. If you like it, forget to adopt it!
Professor Xu, a doctoral supervisor of the Chinese Department of Nanjing University, said: "Although there are different opinions on Zhao Lihua's poems on the Internet at present, at least it shows that everyone is still very concerned about the fate and future of China's new poems!"
He believes that one of the reasons why Zhao Lihua's poems have aroused such a strong reaction on the Internet is "obvious colloquial writing" and "this issue has been debated". For example, he said that the poet Ai Qing wrote an article "The Prose Beauty of Poetry" in 1939, which mentioned that a worker wrote a notice on the wall: "An Ming, remember that car!" Ai Qing thinks, "This is beautiful. It should be a talented poet who wrote this notice." However, when Ai Qing published On Poetry on 1980, he "changed this sentence to' This is beautiful, and the person who wrote this notice should have the talent of a poet'!"
Professor Xu said: "The change of adjectives before and after also shows the change of Mr. Ai Qing's attitude towards oral writing. Not to mention great poets, not to mention ordinary netizens? If evaluated normally, it will still promote the progress of poetry. However, if a person named Chen Xiuyuan says,' She is unwilling to be lonely and deliberately grandstanding, which is the same as peeing in the street to attract others' attention', it is inappropriate! "
He further pointed out: "In the Tang Dynasty, although there were some vernacular poems, such as" The foot of the bed is as bright as a thread "and" Climbing over the eaves and climbing over the walls, three thousands of feet ",were these really vernacular poems? These poems are vernacular in isolation, but they are not vernacular in the whole poem. How can there be seven or five words in a vernacular, rhyming and even? Many poems seem to be vernacular on the surface, but they are actually processed. The processed unnatural language with distinct rhythm is the biggest feature that distinguishes the poetic language from novels and other literary works. From this point of view, even if the three words of Fu Xuan in the Jin Dynasty are faint, I feel it. Tilt your ears, not the sound of cars. " Can't say it's vernacular! "
focus
Wang Zhuohua, a doctoral student at Nanjing Normal University College, fully affirmed Professor Xu's point of view: "The original intention of oral writing is to make poetry popular, but the popularity is not all colloquial, and colloquialism cannot be separated from certain rules." Wang Zhuohua said, "I seldom pay attention to new poetry because I feel that new poetry has been possessed."
Wang Zhuohua's poems have at least two characteristics. "One is musicality, that is, the beauty of rhythm and rhythm in the form of poetry. Second, true temperament, that is, the authenticity and individuality of thought, is divorced from these two characteristics of poetry and can only be reduced to a broken line and a disease-free groan! "
Dr. Fu Yuanfeng from the Chinese Department of Nanjing University also writes poems, and he has been paying attention to the development of poetry.
In an interview, he bluntly said: "This is not a poetic phenomenon, but a network phenomenon and a cultural phenomenon."
He believes that "the so-called' pear style' is only a small part of Zhao Lihua's works, but it is not these so-called' pear style' that truly represents Zhao Lihua's level, and Zhao Lihua cannot represent China's current level of poetry creation."