The Relationship between Astronomy and Astrology —— Does Astronomy Originate from Astrology? Please collect information and answer, thank you!

There is no doubt that astronomy and astrology are homologous. In the 26th century BC, our ancestors set up a special office to observe the astronomical phenomena. The arrangement of Liangzhu cultural tombs is the same as that of Xinsusan, which is proof. At this time, at the end of the clan commune, social division of labor began to appear within the tribe. Nature, the power to observe the celestial phenomena, is naturally in the hands of priests who communicate with God. Other nationalities in the same period should be similar here, and the two words in English are very similar, which is also a kind of evidence.

As for the relationship between astronomy and astrology, there are only three kinds, each with its own origin. Astronomy originated from astrology and vice versa. Before discussing this issue, it is necessary to look at the definitions of the two.

Astronomy: the science of observing and theoretically studying celestial bodies and other cosmic substances.

Astrology: the method by which astrologers observe the positions of celestial bodies, the sun, the moon and the stars and make explanations to predict various things in the world.

There are two significant differences between the two. First, the research object, astronomy is the starry sky, astrology is the personnel; Astronomical observation is the process of research, and astrology is the inference after research. The only intersection between them is the starry sky, but they are actually completely different theoretical systems.

Even in ancient times, Sirius came out with the sun when a meteor passed by. This process can be classified as astronomy, but astrologers seldom go to see meteor showers, right? As for the subsequent inference of personnel, nature has nothing to do with astronomy, and it is indeed the main business of astrology.

In a word, my personal opinion is that astronomy and astrology are two completely different systems under the stars. On the same basis, the two developed independently. Astronomy became a theory much later than astrology, but the development of astronomy is not based on astrology at all, so it is unreasonable to say that astronomy originated from astrology.

Maybe biology can better explain this problem. Comparing astronomy to monkeys, astrology is a rabbit, a primate and a rabbit-shaped order. Monkeys appeared later than rabbits, but did not evolve. The ancestors of these two * * * need to find rodents among rodents. This rodent is the starry sky here.

Personal opinion, for reference only.