According to the post, the important value of this new material lies in that the inscription of the frontier library, which caused the focus of controversy in the red circle, appeared for the second time in another book after a lapse of five years, and there were a lot of handwriting of Mei Daochang in the book. In the past five years, there have been many seals of the Liu family in Shangyuan, but they have never been related to Wen Jie and Wen Jie. But in the newly discovered "Mochou Lake Records", the three are unified. This is a very powerful verification that Mr. Liu Shide's previous textual research on "Mei Fei", "Shangshi" and "Wenjie" in the inscription of Bianji is a person (that is, Liu), which further proves the authenticity and research value of Bianji from another angle. The appearance of new materials has brought a new height and opened a new window for the debate and in-depth study of Bian Ji.
At present, because the new material has just appeared, it has not been appraised by authoritative experts, but it has triggered a heated discussion among Redology netizens. The significance of the seal found in Mochou Lake Records and a lot of information about Liu in the book to the authenticity of Bianji remains to be further verified by all parties!
Mochou Lake was discovered in June, 20 1 1 year, and descendants of Liu were discovered at the end of 20 12. In this year and a half, the dispute between the authenticity of Bian Ji gradually subsided from white-hot to the end. Here, the researchers who advocate the authenticity of the two sides have conducted in-depth research and debate, and attached a series of evidence beneficial to real people, such as Mochou Lake Records, Complete Works of Thirteen Peaks Bookstore, Mr. Shi Baosheng's Ink, Wang Lu Robbery, Meng Jinzhai's Monument Collection, Liu Archives and other materials, as well as the stories of Liu's descendants. With these powerful direct evidences, the researchers of Master and Truth published a series of academic articles in newspapers and magazines, which strongly refuted the master's wrong views and fallacies and proved that Bian Ji was a veritable precious ancient manuscript. For example, Four Essays on Eyebrows-Providing a New Evidence published by Mr. Liu Shide (20 1 kloc-0/004), Five Essays on Mei Fei Book Collection-Answering Mr. Ji Zhiyue's Query (20 12, 01, Cooperate with Mr. Peng Yu), The Collection of Six Comments on Eyebrows-Providing a New Evidence (20 12 03), A Dream of Red Mansions and Liu, a bibliophile, jointly published The Border Collection is indeed an ancient manuscript (Guangming Daily 20 1 2165438+/kloc Mr. Wang Peng published Textual Research on Mochou Lake (Liaoning Daily 201July 18), Evidence speaks louder than words-my opinion on distinguishing Mochou Lake from falsehood, and collected books (A Dream of Red Mansions Research Series 201kl Subjective and false researchers such as Re-examination of Ten Works of A Dream of Red Mansions (II) published by Mr. Ji Zhiyue (Collected Works of A Dream of Red Mansions 201.12.03) and Cao Zhen's Bian Cang Ben and Shang Liu Yuan Zang Yin Tan Pieces (Edited). In addition, Mr. Xiao, who had doubts about Bian Ji, published several issues in The Codex of A Dream of Red Mansions (Journal of A Dream of Red Mansions, No.02, 20 12), and Mr. Gao, who also had doubts about Bian Ji, published The Study of A Dream of Red Mansions.
In addition to the academic articles published in newspapers and periodicals by the above-mentioned researchers of A Dream of Red Mansions, the debate on the authenticity of Bian Zang's books in various online redology forums is more direct and intense. In addition to the above researchers, the participants also include all the red friends who are interested in this topic or advocate a certain point of view. There are many related posts, such as Talking about the Authenticity of Border Collected Books published by Hongyou in the early stage (Fuqinju Dream of Red Mansions Literature Community, 2011August 18) and How to Understand published by Hongyou in the later stage. -See Mr. Cao Zhen's response from Peng Yu Xinwen (Fuqinju Dream of Red Mansions Literature Community, 20121.2). The characteristics of these posts are that they can have in-depth and professional discussions on authenticity, and the contents mentioned in the posts also involve all aspects of the dispute between authenticity and falsehood of Bianji.
Mr. Wang's Bian Cang Ben is indeed an ancient manuscript (Guangming Daily 20 1265438+ 10/). There is a sentence at the beginning: "The important information about Liu, the inscription author of Meng Jinzhai Ji Bei, an early manuscript of A Dream of Red Mansions, is a young researcher Wang Peng in Shanghai. This discovery can be called. This is the most formal and direct announcement on behalf of the true party in the authoritative media in China.
It is true that the debate on the authenticity of Bian Ji has aroused widespread concern and fierce controversy in the red circle and on the Internet since the discovery of Bian Ji, and the debate boom has also experienced ups and downs. Compared with previous debates, Mochou Lake Records has been characterized by a deep-seated debate between truth and falsehood driven by new evidence and new materials since its discovery. The new evidence leads to new debates, which in turn promotes the efforts to update the evidence. This is a virtuous cycle of interaction until the problem is finally solved. This fully shows that the end of today's dispute over the authenticity of Bian Ji is the result of the joint efforts of researchers including authenticity and the vast number of red friends. The dispute over the authenticity of Bian's collection of books has laid a distinct brand of redology in the history of redology research in the network age. The significance of this debate lies in providing a scientific demonstration model for the final settlement of all major disputes in the study of A Dream of Red Mansions. The core is that the evidence of "directness in front, and disproof must be excluded" is convincing, so as to make a qualitative conclusion (the language in quotation marks is borrowed from the new book "A Dream of Red Mansions" by Mr. Liu Shide, Postscript II, Social Science Literature Publishing House, the first edition in March, 20 13).