Thanks to Wukong's invitation, the following is Q3' personal opinion. Space is limited, only 65,438+05 people are listed. I won't elaborate on the story. Welcome to add.
wai cao
1, Dong Zhao
Romantic presence: 2 (out of 5, the same below)
Historical existence: 4
Differences in historical romance: 4
Dong Zhao's main role in the romance is that Cao Cao and his son placed chess pieces beside Emperor Xian of Han Dynasty, monitored Emperor Xian of Han Dynasty on weekdays, and forced Emperor Xian of Han Dynasty to promote Cao Cao as the public king. He is very similar to Hua Xin and Marotta in artistic image. In short, he is a villain who flatters the powerful and traitors, bullies the weak and fears the hard, and specializes in dirty work.
Dong Zhao in history is not a nobody, he is an excellent think tank in Cao Wei Group. Born in Yanzhou, he was an able official under Yuan Shao and fled to JASON ZHANG for fear. In the process of Xian Di's eastward relocation and capital relocation to Xuchang, he helped Cao Cao to check and balance all parties and play games with Bai Bo warlords such as Yang Feng, which can be said to be indispensable. Later, he made great contributions in the war to pacify Hebei. After Guo Jia's death, he replaced as a military adviser and continued to fight with the army.
2. Zhong You
Romantic presence: 2
Historical existence: 4
Differences in historical romance: 3
Zhong You in Romance of the Three Kingdoms doesn't have many opportunities to appear in the camera, and he doesn't know what he is doing most of the time. The western battlefield was not the main plot line before Ma Chao's rebellion. Later scenes were all where Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi were, and nothing happened to him.
Zhong You, a great calligrapher in history, is also very clever. During his tenure as the governor of Li Si, he resisted Liangzhou warlords and United with Lian Heng, maintaining balance and stability. He also led Marten Han Sui and others to help Cao Cao pacify Bing. More importantly, he killed his nephew and was loyal to Yuan Shang's national source. After the establishment of Wei, he was first the minister of Dali Temple and then the prime minister, and was highly valued.
Step 3 be happy
Romantic presence: 3
Historical existence: 4
Differences in historical romance: 4
Lejin is a big experience package in Romance of the Three Kingdoms. As long as he is a famous star, he can be abused. His identity is often understood by readers as a professional assistant for 200 years. For example, follow Xia Houdun to Bowangpo, and follow Zhang Liao to keep in harmony, and so on. Moreover, in romantic movies, Le Jin's best skill is stabbing in the back, so it's quite disgusting.
In the official history, Le Jin was not so timid. Surrounded by Cao Cao, he attacked the city and pulled out the village first, and even led the troops to repel Guan Yu in the Xiangfan War. During his stay in Hefei, he was on a par with Zhang Liao. The only general among the five generals of Cao Wei who went to war with Cao Cao when he started his army.
4. thomas lee
Romantic presence: 1
Historical existence: 3
Differences in historical romance: 2
When it comes to Li Tong, few people who have read the Romance may know it, but only vaguely remember that this person seems to have shown his face when Guan Yu surrounded Coss.
In the official history, he is a second-tier star on par with Wen Pin and others. He played the same role as Li Dian in Cao Wei camp, and was a general with his own exclusive army. In the battle of Guandu, he helped Cao Cao stabilize the southern battlefield in the great environment where everyone was in danger, which can be described as loyal. Coss was besieged by Fancheng, and Li Tong came to the rescue in spite of illness and died on the way.
5. Guo Huai
Romantic presence: 3
Historical existence: 4
Differences in historical romance: 4
When it comes to Guo Huai, romance fans will probably think, isn't he Governor Cao Wei who was shot by Jiang Wei?
Yes, in romance, the brilliant moment of his appearance was when Jiang Wei was played and shot during the Northern Expedition. However, Guo Huai in history is not a simple figure. He is the famous Cao Wei who defeated Shu Han's Northern Expedition many times. As early as Liu Bei's crusade against the Hanzhong War in the summer, he had already made his mark. In the chaotic situation of Xia's murder, Zhang He was elected as handsome, assembled and refused to defend the Hanshui River, which made Liu Bei's main force unable to go any further. Until Cao Shuaijun arrived, Liu Bei was forced to turn to attack.
Shuhan kingdom
1, Liu Ba
Romantic existence: 0
Historical existence: 4
Differences in historical romance: 4
Liu Ba may not be known to many people. I don't remember romance telling his story. Historically, he was Liu Bei's first-line counselor and a rare civil servant who was proficient in economy.
There is a doomed love between him and Liu Bei. Liu Ba despises Liu Bei, who wants Liu Ba. The two men chased each other and finally reunited in Shu. At this time, Liu Ba could not return to Cao Cao, and at the same time he was impressed by Liu Bei's "true feelings". Fortunately, he voted for Liu Bei. After voting for Liu Bei, he did nothing in Shu camp, devoted himself to serving the public and making suggestions for the group. I think this is a professional talent, like Xu Shu in romance novels, who is a professional slave. At that time, Liu Bei took Shu and was short of money for fear of provoking public anger. What should I do? Liu Ba made a move to drive out good money with bad money. Although it temporarily destroyed Shu's economy, Liu Bei obtained Hanzhong's military resources through disguised search.
2. Xu Jing
Romantic presence: 1
Historical existence: 3
Differences in historical romance: 2
Who's Xu Jing? I guess many people don't know. But I vaguely remember that when Zhuge Liang and others wrote that Liu Bei proclaimed himself, Xu Jing and Mi Zhu seemed to be ahead of Zhuge Liang, right? Mi Zhu is a prince's maternal uncle and a veteran. What balcony is this?
Xu Jing has many connections. Have you ever heard of Yuedan Review? This was done by him and his relative Xu Shao. Xu Shao is Xu Zijiang, and he is a master who evaluates Cao Cao as a "capable minister of ruling the world and a traitor in troubled times". Xu Jing's specialty is also a lover, and his reputation is not inferior to that of Xu Shao at that time. At that time, balcom fled to Jiaozhou, Liu Zhang was recruited into Shu, and balcom was presented. After Liu Bei won the Shu land, it is natural to continue to provide this flag map.
3. Ma Zhong
Romantic presence: 4
Historical existence: 3
Difference degree of historical romance: 1
The first killer of romance is Ma Zhong. Guan Yu was captured by him and Huang Zhong was killed by him. He killed two generals of the Five Tigers. But that's Ma Zhong of Wu. . . Is Pan Zhang's men, Pan Zhang did capture guan yu, but didn't kill huang zhong.
Ma Zhong in Shu is a historical figure. If the Five Tigers belong to the first generation of Shu Han talents, then he belongs to the second generation of Shu Han talents. He performed well in Zhuge Liang's era, followed the Southern Expedition and Northern Expedition, and was appointed as the fourth governor, guarding the southern border provinces. Because of Ma Zhong's outstanding performance in The Romance, Ma Zhong, the state of Shu, is easily overlooked.
4. Deng Zhi
Romantic presence: 3
Historical existence: 4
Difference degree of historical romance: 1
The most outstanding performance of Deng Zhi in Romance should be that after Liu Bei's death, he sent an envoy to Wudong to mend the relationship between the two families and followed Zhao Zilong's Northern Expedition as a suspected soldier.
In fact, the peak of Deng Zhi in history was after Zhuge Liang's death. Deng Zhi was appointed Governor of Jiangzhou and Prime Minister of the Eastern Front, and made great contributions to Wuhan Huimeng. And so on, equivalent to Man Chong of Cao Wei.
5. Zhang Yi
Romantic presence: 1
Historical existence: 4
Zhang Yi's performance in romance is actually very disgraceful. He assassinated his boss, took refuge in Liu Bei and joined the army with Jiang Wei.
Zhang Yi in history is very beautiful. He did well in the battle of Hanzhong initiated by Liu Bei, and later became the third surrendered governor. It is also a rare senior general in the Shu-Han camp who dares to directly challenge Jiang Wei and oppose the Northern Expedition.
Wu Dong
Zhu Gejin 1
Romantic presence: 4
Historical existence: 4
Differences in historical romance: 2
Many scenes in the Romance of Zhuge Liang are like flowers. His brother Zhu Gejin is a green leaf, while his younger brother Zhuge Liang is not even a flower stem. In romance novels, Zhu Gejin, like Lu Su, is a doormat sandwiched between Soochow and Shu Han. Especially after Lu Su's death, Zhu Gejin's appearance rate increased obviously, and he took over completely.
In the history of Zhu Gejin, it can be considered as civil and military. From the official to the general of Soochow, he participated in the Northern Expedition of Soochow many times and was also a big coffee.
2. Lv Dai
Romantic presence: 1
Historical existence: 3
Differences in historical romance: 3
In romance novels, Wu Dong has always belonged to a working group with few scenes and dirty work. A large number of famous players have become walk-ons. Compared with the hacked Cao Wei generals, Dongwu famous soldiers had no chance to play at all. Lv Dai is the representative of this group of famous players.
Not to mention romance, Lv Dai in history is easily overlooked. But he is really a big coffee. In the process of pacifying Jiaozhou, he made great contributions and became the first secretariat of Guangzhou (Haidong four counties). Lv Dai's main battlefield was in the south all his life, and he was regarded as a narrow-minded figure in Wu Dong government, but he could only miss the main line in romance novels.
3. Zhu Ran
Romantic presence: 1
Historical existence: 3
Differences in historical romance: 3
In the romance, I followed Lu Xun in Yiling. There is basically no chance to show up, and occasionally guests run away.
Zhu Ran in history is the son of Zhi Zhu, the barrier of Soochow Jingzhou, with outstanding ability. Once defending Jiangling City, Cao Zhen, Zhang He, Xia Houshang and others of Cao Wei were besieged for half a year, but Cheng Wei did not fall, which made him an enemy.
4. Huan Zhu
Romantic presence: 1
Historical existence: 3
Differences in historical romance: 2
Born in the Zhujiajian family of four in Wu Dong, Zhang Zhu, Lu Gu. Ruxu once defeated Cao Ren in the battle, but Xinmeile Co., Ltd. was captured alive. Huan Zhu also took part in World War I, in which Zhou Biao plotted to defeat Cao Xiu. However, these are basically mentioned in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. However, because these times deviate from the main line, they are generally ignored.
5. Lv Fan
Romantic presence: 1
Historical existence: 4
Differences in historical romance: 4
Lv Fan in romance films belongs to all kinds of walk-on. Because he is neither a warrior nor a civil servant, it is difficult for him to rehearse.
Lv Fan is a very important figure in the history of Wu Dong. Without Zhou Yu, there would be no Dongwu, and without Lv Fan, there would be no slips. This is not to say that Lv Zhi has great kindness to slips, but that he is very important to slips.
Lv Fan is a very inspiring figure with a humble background. She was rejected by her mother-in-law when she proposed. Don't bully the poor. Lv Fan followed his example in the early days of Sun Ce's business. At that time, Tao Qian tried to control Sun Ce's family, and Lv Fan was ordered to take over. After many twists and turns and risks, Sun Quan's family (including Sun Quan) broke free from the clutches of Tao Qian under the condition of being wanted all over the country. This contribution is no less than Zhao Zilong's rescue of Adou in Changbanpo. Sun Ce regards him as a brother, and Sun He, a relative of Sun Ce, is a close minister, and his treatment is no less than that of Zhou Yu. Sun Ce's task, Lv Fan can always be accomplished brilliantly.
In the era of Sun Quan, it was Lv Fan, not Zhou Yu, who proposed to imprison Liu Bei. It was only at that time that Sun Quan disagreed. Lv Fan's treatment has always been clan level, which has never changed. It is said that Sun Quan has a dark belly and many taboos, but no matter how luxurious and dignified Lv Fan is, Sun Quan has always endured it, and even regarded Lv Fan as his own haing s ngor (the founding father of the Eastern Han Dynasty) and gave Lv Fan a heavy burial.