?
Comment on Border Town Fan Wenxuan 1
? When I first read Border Town in middle school, I was in a hurry and a little anxious. I just want to find Cui Cui's love destiny in the book. After reading it, I was deeply touched and lamented. What impressed me most was that at first I didn't understand the "thin and desolate smell" that Cui Cui felt in that beautiful evening. After thinking for a long time, I seem to have a vague feeling. I remember that feeling for a long time afterwards.
? The second time I watched Border Town, I was a freshman. I was influenced by literature in the College of Literature, so I stopped rushing to the plot and read it carefully. What I see is no longer just the love story of Promise and Tianbao, but more about the quiet and beautiful world described in the book, and I realize the simplicity, kindness and sincerity of human nature. After reading it, I also read Shen Congwen's biography and some appreciation articles, knowing Shen Congwen's special feelings for that land and his quaint writing language is concise and vivid, close to life. After that, I looked back at Border Town, and it was another taste in my heart.
? I read Border Town three times today, and I have accumulated a lot of literary theory knowledge, but I can only be silent. After reading it calmly, I still have a faint sadness in my heart, which I can't let go for a long time. "Beauty can make people's hearts fragile", suddenly thinking of this sentence, I feel the same way.
? Mr. Shen Congwen wrote in the inscription on the border town: "Therefore, even if this work conforms to a certain literary theory, critics will praise it in various ways, and this criticism will inevitably become an insult to the author. They don't want to know the true love, hate, sorrow and joy of this nation, so they can't explain the gains and losses of this work-this book is not written for them. ..... I will briefly describe the worries of some small people in the process of change when this nation moves towards the unknown fate brought by history, as well as the thoughts and desires of' living' and' how to live' caused by insufficient nutrition. " I realized that silence suits me. I can't understand the true love, hate, sadness and joy of this nation. I have no right to comment on Border Town. Although there are flattering words hidden in my heart, I want to speak, but I can't find the right words to express them. In the words of Mr. Shen Lao, this kind of praise "will inevitably become an insult to the author." I think it is not only the author who is insulted, but also Border Town. Perhaps "Border Town" itself is the best interpretation and summary of "Border Town". Besides, any comment on Border Town is clumsy. In front of a work like Border Town, just enjoy it quietly and read it carefully.
? Last year, the TV series "Bloody Xiangxi" was a hit, and I was waiting. The TV picture is beautiful, the plot is ups and downs, love and hate, life and death, which can be described as wonderful and moving. At that time, I always thought that "Bloody Xiangxi" was adapted from "Border Town", and the two were very similar. I don't agree with the third reading of Border Town today.
? I think Border Town is not only Shen Congwen's hometown, but also your hometown, my hometown and everyone's hometown.
? Comment on Selected Border Town 2
? The tea cave depicted in Shen Congwen's Border Town is a fantastic place with beautiful scenery. In such a beautiful place, everything is simple, life is simple, customs are simple, and even love is simple. There is a family under the White Pagoda next to the tea cave-an old ferryman, his granddaughter Cui Cui and a yellow dog. One year during the Dragon Boat Festival, they were separated from her grandfather, but they happened to get the help of the general manager of the ship, Nuo, and returned home. At that moment, they went to Seeds of Love. Who knows, God bless also fell in love with Cui Cui, but God bless finally helped him go out and run to the beach, but he was killed, so his parents left Cui Cui, and the old boatman suddenly left on a thunderstorm day because he was worried about Cui Cui's marriage. Everything has passed, but that beautiful love is lingering in the reader's memory.
? Although Border Town is a tragedy, the story of parents singing love songs for Cui Cui is extremely beautiful. Yes, the road looks smooth, but it can't be compared with the romance on the road. The beauty of the whole story lies in this winding road, which is the simplest love, and it is this simple and romantic love that really touched Cui Cui's heart. This story also explains the feelings between boys and girls.
? However, in the whole love, Cui Cui seems to play a leading role. Cui Cui likes his parents, which Cui Cui must know. Parents also like Cui Cui, which originally hit it off, but Cui Cui was too shy to even say "yes". Such a tragedy can also be said to be caused by Cui Cui. There is nothing wrong with shyness itself, but sometimes you have to be decisive in the face of such things, because in the face of simple people, excessive shyness may be more terrible than anything else.
? Comment on Border Town 3
? "Border Town" describes the tortuous love between Tianbao Henuo, two sons of Shancheng Chadong Wharf Group, and Cui Cui, the granddaughter of the ferryman. In a remote town with beautiful scenery and simple human feelings in Xiangxi, there are two grandparents and grandchildren who live by ferry. Grandpa is over 70 years old and still strong; Granddaughter Cui Cui is 15 years old and is the seed of love. They are warm and helpful, simple and kind. Two years ago, during the Dragon Boat Festival, Cui Cui met the second young master of the local boatman and planted the seedlings of love. Tianbao, the brother sent by Nuo, likes beautiful and pure, and asks people to ask for relatives from his grandfather. The local Wang Tuan has always taken a fancy to Nuosong and is willing to take the mill as a dowry to marry his daughter to Nuosong. I would rather be a ferryman than a miller. I want to marry Cui Cui. So the two brothers agreed to sing and propose marriage, and let Cui Cui choose. Tianbao knows that Cui Cui likes to send promises. In order to fulfill his younger brother, he went out to the beach and died unexpectedly. Northong felt responsible for his brother's death, so he left Cui Cui and ran away from home. Grandpa worried about Cui Cui's marriage and died on a stormy night. Leave a man guarding the ferry and wait for promise to come back. "This man may never come back, maybe he will come back tomorrow!"
? Border Town has entrusted Shen Congwen's aesthetic ideals of "beauty" and "love", and it is one of his works that can best express the beauty of human nature. By describing the love tragedy of Xiangxi's daughter and lover Nuo, this novel reflects the painful fact that Xiangxi people can't grasp their own destiny in the face of "nature" and "personnel". So is Cui Cui, and so is Cui Cui's mother. They repeated their sad and desolate lives from generation to generation, but they couldn't find a way to get rid of this fate. Through the love tragedy Border Town, Shen Congwen reveals the mystery of the fate of the characters and praises the innocent hearts of the border people.
? Border Town expresses the beauty of human nature by describing the pure love between young men and women, the sincere love between grandparents and grandchildren, and the kindness and mutual love between neighbors. The author wants to dilute the darkness and pain of reality and eulogize an ancient human nature and lifestyle symbolizing "love" and "beauty" through the love tragedy of Nuo. He Nuo bid farewell to the young people he deeply loved, neither pledging eternal love, being very much in love, nor doing anything out of line, nor trading power and money covered in copper, only the natural feelings between men and women bred in the primitive countryside, as fresh and healthy as flowers in the sun. The author not only warmly praised the way the two young people treated "love", but also enthusiastically eulogized the nobleness of Xiangxi people's behavior and the beauty of their souls. Border Town is Shen Congwen's masterpiece, which shows readers the harmonious life form of Xiangxi world.
? Nowadays, the relationship between people seems so strange and utilitarian. For their own interests, everyone seems to be involved in the trend of fighting each other. While the architectural space is getting narrower and narrower, people's hearts are also narrow; In today's convenient transportation, the way of communication between people is so convenient, but the communication between people is so difficult. A wall not only isolates the living place between people, but also isolates the spiritual communication between people; A security door seems to avoid the intrusion of outsiders, but it also imprisons its contact with the outside world.
? In Border Town, we can see people's simple, frugal, friendly and peaceful scenes. "The person who manages this ferry is an old man who lives under the tower. I lived for seventy years, and I have been staying by this stream since I was twenty. I don't know how many years have passed in these fifty years. Although he is so old, he should rest, but the sky doesn't allow him to rest. It seems that he can't live without this life. He never considered the significance of his position to himself, but lived there quietly and faithfully. " When writing about the hero Cui Cui, it is like this: "Nature has nurtured her and educated her, so it is innocent and lively, and looks like a small animal everywhere. People are so good, like deer on the mountain, never consider cruelty, never worry, never get angry. Usually, when strangers pay attention to her on the ferry, they look at strangers with bare eyes and make it look like they can escape into the mountains at any time, but after understanding people's inorganic heart, they play leisurely by the water. " When writing about the smooth operation of the water terminal, the article said: "This generous and free-spirited person, although his career is smooth, is generous and able to help others because he is willing to make friends, ... understands the hardships of outsiders and the feelings of frustrated people ... but he is so impartial and selfless ... both upright and peaceful, and does not love money." When it comes to these two young people, it is so popular: "strong as an ox ... bold and open-minded, unconventional ... be kind to relatives, not arrogant and lazy, flashy."
? ? Comment on Border Town 4
? Shen Congwen's novels depict the beautiful scenery of Xiangxi border town with quiet style, prose style and poetic artistic conception. The world in the border town is simple, kind, quiet and peaceful, and the simplest feelings flow between people.
? I was moved by Cui Cui's simplicity and cuteness. "Innocent and lively, like a little beast everywhere. People are so good, just like the yellow deer on the mountain. They have never thought about cruelty, never worried, and never got angry. " "When I met a stranger on the ferry and paid attention to her, I looked at the stranger with my bare hands as if I could escape to the mountains at any time, but when I understood that the person in front had no intention of taking the opportunity, I played leisurely by the water." In Mr. Shen Congwen's pen, the image of a little girl who was born with education came alive. Cui Cui is the embodiment of truth, goodness and beauty, but life is cruel and realistic. The great god died unexpectedly, and both parents gave birth to a knot because of the stillbirth of the old man. Grandpa died of illness because he was worried about Cui Cui's life, and three people who deeply loved Cui Cui finally left her. But life has to go on. Cui Cui's father's colleague Ma Lao Bing and Cui Cui live together in Bixi Village. The young man who sang in the moonlight and let Cui Cui float his soul gently because he sang in his sleep may never come back, maybe he will come back tomorrow.
? I was moved by this simple and kind world, "Don't cry! Stop crying! Listen to me, I know everything in grandpa's heart, I have everything; I will arrange your affairs and live up to your grandfather. I'll arrange it. I will make every effort. I want to find someone who is happy with grandpa and you to receive this ferry. It can't be what we want. Although I am old, I can still fight them with a sickle. Cui Cui, don't worry, I have everything! ..... "These sincere words and actions are very rare in today's society. It is precisely because of the friendship between people and the lack of trust that they yearn for the small town described in Border Town and expect all the truth, goodness and beauty to happen.
? Knowing that time was running out, the old boatman dragged his sick body to find lifelong support, but he was given a cold shoulder by his father and son. When the old boatman passed away quietly on that thunderstorm night, his heart was full of disappointment and worry, and my tears could not help flowing down.
? At the end of the article, the white tower that fell in the storm has been rebuilt. The author seems to want to tell us that although many things that died in the storm can't come back, the living will continue to live after the storm.
? Comment on Border Town 5
? In this noisy era, I hold a copy of Border Town in my hands and read it silently, as if I were in a paradise. In Xiangxi, an international city with a clear breeze and bright moon, there is a beautiful image of natural condensation, and she is Cui Cui.
? The sunshine is not as warm as her failure, and the green water is not as warm as her Ming Che eyes. Cui Cui was born between the quiet Liuhe in Xiangxi, and the green mountains and green waters gave her a natural face to carve. Her surface is so beautiful, the natural landscape nourishes her watery appearance and endows her with a simple personality. On the edge of the bamboo forest in Xiangxi, she and her grandfather lived together, and there was sweet love between them in ordinary days. Surrounded by the green water of Xiangxi, she grew up in the subtle influence of her grandfather. Unconsciously, the unique kindness and diligence of Xiangxi people penetrated into Cui Cui's thoughts. Cui Cui's heart is more beautiful, so beautiful that people can't put it down.
? I like the beauty and simplicity of Cui Cui. She is hardworking and kind, and can make people see through everything at a glance. Between the green mountains and green waters, she ferried with her grandfather, and this payment has never been related to money; At the edge of the moonlight bamboo forest, she had a close conversation with her grandfather, and the sparrow-like laughter swirled in the ravine; In the morning fog river, she waited for a long time and paddled hard. In the face of plain and poor life, she never gave birth to a trace of complaint. What pure beauty! It really makes people feel a little pity from the bottom of their hearts. Her sincerity is the breeze fluttering in the ravine, and it is like the sunshine penetrating through thousands of layers of sea of clouds, which goes straight into the depths of the years and infects many people with shiny surfaces and messy backs. Today's flower international, a long time, this simple truth, goodness and beauty.
? I like the beauty of Cui Cui's natural scenery. Shen Congwen's delicate brushstrokes outline such a shy girl, who is like a delicate rose, facing the world with beautiful flowers in bud. The ignorance of meeting for the first time, the shyness of reunion, and the girl's little mind are so beautiful. Although she is young, she is frank and natural. Look at those who manage the world. What they are afraid of is to polish a rich and numb heart in a dirty world.
? I also like the beauty of Cui Cui. Although her image has always made people feel warm, there is no lack of wordless sadness between the lines. This small shortcoming may not be able to integrate into this unsatisfactory international community after all. Whether it is a regrettable ending or an unspoken feeling in the book, this beauty is branded with a bitter mark. But in this international society, how many volumes of true stories are satisfactory? How many beautiful books are on my back, without pain and melancholy? Because of regret, Cui Cui is real. Her regret is exactly the regret of this international community. The beauty of contentment does not exist in this world. And that is just a step away, that is, a hurdle that we should strive to cross on the road of life.
? Comment on Border Town 6
? Cui Cui, the heroine in Border Town, is the embodiment of purity and beauty and the beautiful soul of Border Town. Grandpa the old boatman is a simple but stubborn old man. He is confident and proud of the beauty of Cui Cui. In order to marry Cui Cui into a good family, he is poor and humble regardless of his position, and his inner worries and responsibilities are intertwined. Shunshun, a former exiled official of Qing Dynasty, managed wooden boats, had a certain savings, and his career was booming. Because of generosity and loyalty, he is known as a heroic gentleman on the side of "Zhangshui Wharf". His two sons "Da Lao" and "Raul" were educated by their father's Jianghu manners, and they were beaten and tempered in the waves, and they all became smart and handsome teenagers in the Jianghu "Yue Yun" style. After crossing the river or catching ducks, the two brothers fell in love with Cui Cui at first sight and fell in love with the beautiful Cui Cui. The "second old man" told Cui Cui that he would rather have a broken ferry than the "new mill". Tianbao, the "predecessor", never gave up the pursuit of beauty in the chaotic "road" and "car road" rejection with Cui Cui. After getting to know each other, these two persistent brothers resolutely stood on the cliff covered with moonlight and sang "Three Years and Six Months" for Cui Cui.
? Border Town is a love tragedy. It seems that the words are carefully chosen, but in fact the pen and ink are faint and dignified. Her touching is the beauty of love tragedy. Mr. Shen's delicate and youthful life vividly depicts a girl's shyness, trance and indifference, representing the hazy change of her mind. It is a tragedy that Cui Cui, who has never had a mother's love and has never been involved in the world as a woman, is at a loss in the face of infatuation, burying herself again and again, avoiding shirking, and finally waiting in depression. On the cliff, Tianbao and Nuonuo can no longer hear the folk songs that send their brothers to the moonlit night. Tianbao drowned in the whirlpool. In addition to his sadness, Nuo refused to accept the urging of the "new mill" at home and went to the distant "Taoyuan" land. At this heartbreaking moment, after Grandpa ate "a stuffy fist" at the water pier, the White Pagoda in Bixi Village finally collapsed on that night of heavy rain and thunder. The only relative of Cui Cui, an old boatman who worked hard all his life, died in his sleep in anxiety and expectation. In the narrative of Yang and others, I understand everything. She cried all night, but the years like songs flowed away like a white river.
? The end of Border Town is also very tragic and profound, with a deep artistic conception: "In winter, the collapsed white tower was repaired again. However, the boy who sang under the moon and let Cui Cui drift gently because he sang in his sleep has not returned to the tea cave. "
? "…………。"
? "This person may never come back, maybe" Tomorrow "!" Mr. Shen's exquisite poetic embellishment has left people with long regrets and infinite worries and expectations.
? ? Comment on Border Town 7
? In the dead of night, avoid the hustle and bustle of the city during the day, immerse yourself in the silence, and read "Border Town" in your own Xiaotian field, and your thoughts fluctuate with the changes of the characters in the book.
? Border Town is a love story with a simple and beautiful plot. The two sons of Shunshun Zhangshui Wharf in Chadong, a mountain city in western Hunan, were blessed by Tianbao and Nuosong, and at the same time fell in love with Cui Cui, the granddaughter of an old boatman in Bixi. But Cui Cui is in love with Noel. After learning the truth that day, she knew that she couldn't force it. She took the initiative to quit the competition and boarded a ship in Chenzhou to forget everything there, but she was unfortunately killed. Although Northong always loved Cui Cui, his brother died for it, which made him very depressed, misunderstood the old boatman and left home for Taoyuan in pain. And Cui Cui alone bears all the changes, waiting, waiting for the person who may never come back, maybe tomorrow.
? The beauty and desolation in the world are vividly reflected in the article. Cui Cui and grandpa's deep friendship, nature protection and sending off the brotherhood of the two brothers, harmonious and simple neighborhood relationship between grandparents and villagers, unity of man and nature, simple folk customs. ...
? Or perhaps beautiful scenery, loud gongs and drums, and lively festivals have attracted people's attention and covered up the sadness and pain behind the happiness and auspiciousness. However, the author's fresh and meaningful brushwork is indeed somewhat sad. Just like here, there are also the parting and death of relatives, full of unsuccessful expectations, and ignorant, hazy, but endless love. ...
? Sometimes, we see the prosperity, but we can't see through the sadness behind the prosperity. We have experienced the noise, but we have never thought whether loneliness will sublimate after the end of the song.
? Sometimes, we see the phenomenon, but we can't get rid of the fog. Sometimes, it's hard to clarify what we don't say and it's hard to say it again.
? Everyone can choose his own path, but for a long time, life is like a river, with twists and turns, but it will never turn back.
? We always can't catch something and can't change something. Behind the beauty is endless desolation. Just like Cui Cui, a beautiful child, he finally had to be alone by the river.
? The sadness here is an indelible drop of ink, which drips into the heart and entangles, then dries up and condenses there and cannot be erased. Only the clear river is still telling those old stories. ...
? Comment on Border Town 8
? Gently open the page, "there is a stream by the stream, and there is a small white tower by the stream." There lived a single family, an old man, a girl and a yellow dog under the tower ... "
? Cui Cui and her grandfather lived together by ferry in 15, which ushered in her love choice. Big Brother always liked Cui Cui, but his death made things different: Second Brother was no longer so determined to marry Cui Cui, and the ship began to be biased against Grandpa. Then a storm took away Grandpa's past life, and perhaps it also shattered Cui Cui's budding happiness.
? Everything around is so quiet and serene. This kind of life is like a calm lake, clear as practice, but without a ripple. But it is such a tragedy, such as a stone falling into a pool, causing ripples, and the peace of her life is broken. But she still weaves grasshoppers, ferries, sings fishing songs and plays the flute every day, but there is a secret hidden in her heart, a secret that even grandpa can't tell. The quaint blue tiles, the towering corner of the pavilion, and the ancient wind chimes under the eaves gently ring with the wind, as if hitting the heart directly, once and for all ... The author downplayed the poor life of Cui Cui and her grandfather with fresh and meaningful language, but vividly described the harmonious coexistence of nature and villagers, simple life, natural folk customs and kind nature ... Perhaps the beautiful scenery and lively festivals attracted people's attention and covered up the peace of the festival.
? Border Town, like a cold flute, rolled through my mind, leaving a faint desolation and sadness. Clear and winding rivers, clear and clear sky, simple mountain villages surrounded by mountains. "A round of setting sun is lying in the water, half of the river is rustling and half of the river is red." Whose song bypasses the distant haze at dusk, melts the vigorous pine and cypress, whimpers gently and lingers on the river bank for a long time. ...
? A quiet and simple city exists from beginning to end, telling the fate of Cui Cui. Let people sincerely express sympathy for Cui Cui. But life is like this, like a river, with twists and turns and ups and downs, but it will never end. No one's life is smooth sailing, but as long as you face it bravely, you can always meet the dawn of victory and perhaps find the true meaning of life in adversity. Just like Hawking is studying in an illness, Helen Keller lives in darkness, and Tai Lihua dances in a silent world! Behind the beauty is endless desolation. Just like Cui Cui, a beautiful child will eventually have to dream by the river alone. In the dead of night, avoid the noise of the city during the day and immerse yourself in silence: "That person will never come back, maybe tomorrow ..."
? Comments on Border Town 9
? The first contact with Mr. Shen Congwen's works was The Journey to the West, which was in the summer vacation of 20xx, at Quelin National School in Shaoyang, Hunan. Every morning, when I walk on the playground, I will read this book. Looking back on life at that time, it was really pleasant. At that time, my location was less than 300 kilometers away from Xiangxi written by Mr. Shen Congwen, which was my dream place.
? When I didn't open this book, my mind was full of this sentence: "Border Town is a Besieged City". People outside the city want to go in, and people in the city want to come out. "This is my first impression of Border Town. This sentence often comes to mind when reading this book. Is this sentence correct? Why do city people go out? Why do people from outside the city want to come in?
? After reading this book, I have my own answer. I think this sentence can be understood from two angles.
? One is that as readers, we come from outside the city, while the characters depicted in the book come from inside the city. It is natural for people outside the city to want to go in, because the border town is a quiet and peaceful city, and people here live a leisurely life. This is a paradise written by Mr. Shen Congwen, and he has placed his beautiful expectations and yearning.
? As for whether the city people want to come out or not, I don't know, because we are not city people, so we dare not jump to conclusions.
? The second point of view, purely from the perspective of the story. There is a river between the city and the city, with emerald green on one side and natural forest protection and delivery on the other. Because of the pursuit of love, people in the city want to go in and people outside the city want to come out. Because it was just "thinking", it didn't come true, which also corresponds to the unsatisfactory ending of the novel.
? As a novella, Border Town brings me the most beautiful experience and feeling, which is the endless reverie left at the end of the novel. Each of us can enter the book through the words in the book, play the role we want to play, go through our own experiences one by one and move on, which gives each of us the opportunity to become an author. In this sense, Border Town is an unfinished painting and an unfinished poem.
? Later, although I have been to Hunan many times, I have not been able to visit and feel the border town written by Mr. Shen Congwen because of time. I hope I can have another chance next time.
? Comment on the selected border town 10
? Grandfather is getting old day by day. "Anyway, let Cui Cui have a landing." . At first, my grandfather didn't know that the two best young people in the tea cave were "ferry boats" with inheritance, and sent their parents away without even "ferrying" to the mill. At this time, it was a lucky and tragic experience for my grandfather or Cui Cui.
? The straightforward Tianbao elder confessed to Grandpa: "Uncle, your Cui Cui is really beautiful, like a Guanyin. Two years later, if I can stay in the teahouse and take care of things, I won't have to fly around like an old crow. I will definitely come to this stream every night to sing for Cui Cui. " Grandfather looked at the old man with his little eyes. He was looking for such a person. However, the honesty of this elder made my grandfather sad and happy. My grandfather recalled the truth from a man's mouth, which was really sad and happy. He thought to himself, "Is this man fit to take care of Cui Cui? If you really hand him over, will Cui Cui? "Grandpa is looking for someone who can take care of Cui Cui instead of him. The simple old man can't make a good decision, so he has to follow his granddaughter's attitude. Not long after, Nuo sent the second old man to the door to probe his mouth, and said straight to the point like his brother, "Uncle, you are like an adult, and you are very good-looking! "The meaning is clear enough. Cui Cui has grown up. Speaking of marriage, isn't promise giving a hint?
? To compare and analyze, natural forest protection is not as good as Nuopai. Tianbao is "generous and open-minded, and does not stick to the rules." He is the captain's eldest son and should inherit the family business, so he made it clear to his grandfather, "I want a lover who can listen to me sing, but I can't lack a daughter-in-law who takes care of the housework." He is not a delicate person. He probably inherited his father and married a little widow with white face and black hair. In Tianbao's eyes, his family business comes first. Nogo is different. He is "smart and full of emotion". He came not only to show his mind to his grandfather, but also to invite Cui Cui to his home and arrange a seat for her that is most favorable for watching the yacht race. Cui Cui didn't understand what he meant at first, until he heard someone say, "Today, just looking at the strength of the second old man, you can guess that this strength was given to him by a yellow flower girl on the shore!" Cui Cui realized that "my heart is a little confused"
? Both the road and the road go to the same place, but not every effort can get the desired result, no matter how hard you try. Perhaps for Cui Cui, who decides the result, she doesn't care who goes which way, but only cares about one person, a person who exists in her heart.
?