Li Qingzhao, Wang Anshi, Du Mu Why do these three poets have such different evaluations of Xiang Yu’s death?

"Summer Quatrains": Li Qingzhao used it to criticize the shameless behavior of those in power in the Southern Song Dynasty. He used the past to satirize the present and is upright. Obviously, she believed that although Xiang Yu was defeated, he could be called a hero.

"Ti Wu Jiang Pavilion": Du Mu regretted that Xiang Yu committed suicide in anger, but his main intention was to criticize him for not being good at seizing opportunities, not good at listening to other people's suggestions, and not good at recruiting and employing people. Du Mu imagined an opportunity that had not yet materialized, and emphasized that a military strategist must have far-sightedness and indomitable will. He believed that Xiang Yu would become discouraged when he suffered setbacks, and would kill himself in shame, so he could not be considered a true "man".

"Wujiang Pavilion" is a poem written by Wang Anshi in response to Du Mu's poem, which expresses Wang Anshi's views on Xiang Yu's failure. Wang Anshi, based on his own understanding, believed that Xiang Yu's failure was a foregone conclusion. Even if the Jiangdong children were still there, Xiang Yu would not be able to lead the Jiangdong children to come back again, thinking that they might no longer be willing to sacrifice their lives for the war

Different background.

Different understanding