Xin Qiji or Su Shi, whose ci achievement is higher?

Recently, I happened to be reading Su Shi's chronicle annotation and Xin Qiji's chronicle annotation. Both are peaks, but I think Zhou Ji's Miscellaneous Poems of Jiecunzhai summed it up very well: "The world is equal to Su, equal to Xin." Sue is at home, and I can reach her. When Xin is in the right place, Sue will not be able to arrive; The words of two people can't be the same as Japanese. "In fact, according to my understanding, the pattern of Su Shi's works is not as good as that of Xin Qiji." Su is at home, Xin Qiji can write, "In the fragrance of rice and flowers, it is said that there is a good harvest, listening to frogs." "Last night, Songbian was drunk and asked Songsong: How drunk am I? I only suspected that I was here to help her, so I gave her a push and said, "Go!" " This leisure can even be called a lovely sentence. There can also be "forty-three years, looking at the middle, remembering, and bonfire Yangzhou Road." "Who asked, can Lian Po still eat when he is old?" And "I once lived in the north and south of the Yangtze River, and I returned to China with a pale face. Cloth in the autumn night dream, Wan Li is in front of you. " Such a gloomy and responsible sentence. His eyes are on the country and the nation, not just himself. But Su Shi seldom sees the nation in his eyes. He can only see his own happiness and frustration. In Niannujiao Chibi Nostalgia, which is generally regarded as his heroic masterpiece, it was originally heroic and good, and suddenly came a sentence "Life is like a dream, a bottle is still a moon" and suddenly fell into nothingness. I think Dongpo's ci is often from chic to nothingness.

For example, in Dingfengbo, I walked smartly to the pavilion and "spent my life in misty rain". I was broad-minded and carefree. Suddenly I came to the pavilion. "Looking back at the bleak place, I went home, rain or shine." Suddenly there is a feeling of shrinking. There are also Linjiang immortals, whose boat died from now on, and Jiang Hai who stayed for the rest of his life, and Shui Long Yin, who has two rhymes of Zhang Zhifu Huayang Ci, three points for spring scenery, two points for dust and one point for water. It's all quite negative. "Klang Ganzhou, visiting orphans" is simply a capital funeral. "Who is like Dongpo in his later years?" There is also "about returning to the sea in the east, and I hope that Xie Gongya's ambition will not run counter to it." Xizhou Road, don't go back and get my clothes. "I want to ask him, he has been promoted, why are you still so sad and so negative? All kinds of allusions, all kinds of unwillingness to be an official, resignation and seclusion. His early writings were quite colorful. One of them, Lotus Leaf, was regarded as Zhou Bangyan's word by the flowers and plants Nazis, and all kinds of filth in the word could hardly be seen. Of course, many of his words, such as "The water in front of the door is still flowing west, don't sing yellow chickens with white hair" and "Wish people a long journey * * *", are still very positive, and there are also "Snow foam and milk flowers float in the afternoon, wormwood buds try spring vegetables" and so on. "I also like the word' people's taste is pure joy', and I am good at enjoying life.

?