I think that "there are some words in' two thanks' that are entangled and wrong, like the word' forever' under the word' pool', and there is no support in the middle". (Gu Shuhua's Notes on Calligraphy of Song People in Jin, Sui, Tang and Five Dynasties, p. 3 1 p.) Tamia Liu also thinks that the first line of "harmony" is unclear and the second line of "female" has been changed (Complete Works of China's Calligraphy, p. 362). Xu Bangda also said in the article "Fake Calligraphy and Painting" (China Calligraphy and Painting 20 10 09): "Some imitators don't know how to write cursive, and sometimes they make mistakes in Titian's strokes. For example, the Tang people copied the word' Yong' in Wang Xizhi's "Two Thanks" and the word' Yu' in "Feng Ju Tie" (according to the data, it should be "Ping An Tie").
Qi Gong thinks that the five elements of "two thank-you letters" are disjointed and difficult to read. There is a word "don't" at the end of the second line and a word "true" on the right, indicating that there is at least one post in front; The words "left drama" at the end are one line, because it was empty before going forward, not flat content, but should be another post; Three or four lines of handwriting are still different. "So, in order to collect all the notes, I copied" two thank-you letters "."(Quoted from Peng Lizhi's Calligraphy-From Form to Art) The "two thanks" at the beginning of the two thanks are all considered by Xu Bangda and Liu Tao as Xie An and Xie Wan. Xu Bangda said: "In Wang Xizhi's letters,' Xie Xie' is often mentioned, which may be Xie An and Xie Wan. Although there were many people surnamed Xie at that time, Ann and Wan Er were always the closest contacts with Wang. Among the ministers of the right army, there are' Shangshu and Zhonglang', and the two of them are more obvious "(Xu Bangda's" Gu Shuhua's Passing Notes on Song Calligraphy in Jin, Sui, Tang and Five Dynasties "3 1 page).
Tamia Liu also pointed out that it is difficult to define whether "Xie" refers to Chen Jun's Xie brothers, Xie An and Xie Wan, or Xie Shang and Xie Yi. Xie An and Xie Wan are two people closely related to Wang Xizhi. It is recorded in the biography of Wang Xizhi. Both Wang He and Xie belong to a big family in the Eastern Jin Dynasty, and they also have a good in-laws relationship. After the death of Wang Xizhi, Xie An attached great importance to Wang Xianzhi and twice recruited Wang Xianzhi as Sima (Complete Works of China Calligraphy, page 362).
Rong Geng's "two thanks" actually refers to a person. "The second thank you is Yuan, and the right army post repeatedly said, for example, Volume 6 of Pavilion Post said,' It's comfort to receive the second thank you. Sheng Yuan has not yet arrived in the capital "and" Two thanks are here, and they are divided all day long, which is very regrettable "(Wang Xizhi and his ink, Textual Research and Discrimination of 20th Century Calligraphy Research Series, Shanghai Calligraphy and Painting Publishing House, 2000+02, p. 58).