The evaluation of later generations made Yue Fei get what he wanted. How much can he compare with Guan Yu
Item 1: Guan Yu will be stronger in the martial arts competition.
Guan Yu and Yue Fei are both military commanders. According to Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Yue Yue Biography, they all have irresistible courage. Shen Qiang, Yue Fei's Liquan, like Guan Yu's Dragon Crescent Moon Knife, can make it into the top ten in the arsenal spectrum.
Guan Yu's martial arts are very high, which is based on official history. In Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Chen Shou not only recorded the prestige of Guan Yu beheading Yan Liang and Pound at the gate of Xiangyang, but also specifically mentioned Zhang Fei's "final conclusion", saying that Zhang Fei was "just like Guan Yu".
Yue Fei is different. Of course, "picking Xiao Wang with a gun" is fierce and nonsense. Yue Fei experienced countless battles in his life, and many Jurchen generals were beheaded and captured by Yue Jiajun. I don't know which fierce person Yue Fei "clicked" on himself. Every time Yue Fei visits the battlefield in person, he acts as a "flag bearer" instead of competing with the enemy. Yue Jiajun took over the banner of Yue Fei.
The second item: literary talent is better than Guan Yu's love of reading Zuo Zhuan.
According to the biography of Jiang Biao, Guan Yu likes reading Zuo Zhuan. Later, it was said that Guan Yu liked reading Spring and Autumn Annals. Even Guan Yu's couplets in Guandi Temple say that he "learned from the ancients and died in the Spring and Autumn Period." There is nothing special except poetry and calligraphy. " As we all know, Chunqiu and Zuozhuan are not the same thing.
Yue Fei's foundation should be worse. He is a farmer in Tangyin. When he was a child, he worked during the day and his father taught him to read at night.
As an adult, he went to the Han family in Anyang to be a "farmer", first doing farm work and then doing nursing home.
Item 3: The scope of responsibility is larger than Guan Yu's.
After Liu Bei captured Yizhou, Guan Yu was entrusted with the important task of "Jingzhou and Du Dong".
There were seven counties in Jingzhou at the end of Han Dynasty, among which Nanyang was in the hands of Cao Cao, Jiangxia, Changsha and Guiyang were in the hands of Sun Quan, and Guan Yu was able to "supervise Dong", but there were only three counties in Nanjun, Wuling and Lingling.
Yue Fei's territory is much larger. In the last Northern Expedition, Yue Fei's position was Fu Xuan, the ambassador of Beijing Road in West Lake, and recruited the ambassador of Henan North Road. The actual occupied defensive areas are Hubei and southern Henan, and his jurisdiction includes the areas occupied by Jurchen in western Kaifeng, Hubei, Henan and Hebei.
Item 4: Yue Fei is more capable of leading the army than Yue Fei.
How is Guan Yu's army fighting capacity? I don't know. Guan Yu experienced many battles in his life. He followed Liu Bei in his early years and his strength was limited. It is hard to say that there is something wrong with his leadership. Later, the siege of Xiangyang, Megatron of China, the beheading of Pound and the surrender of Coss were all very fierce. But after Cao Cao sent Huang Xu for reinforcements, he didn't get much advantage. Later, when Sun Quan broke his retreat, Guan Yu's army dispersed.
It is easy to shake the mountain, but difficult to shake the Yue family army. Needless to say, YueGuJun fighting capacity, even if jurchen cavalry unstoppable, it is difficult to shake YueGuJun lineup. Yue Fei is also good at ideological work. Commanders and political commissars often give important speeches to soldiers before fighting. The main meaning is that after going to the battlefield, the gun in his hand can still be held firmly, and his mouth is still spitting and swallowing saliva, so he is very brave. That's great.
Item 5: Yue Fei played beautifully in the Northern Expedition, and Guan Yu was more intimidating.
Guan Yu and Yue Fei failed in the Northern Expedition. It's hard to say which is more serious. Guan Yu led the troops to win the battle. There is not much evidence in history books, but Yue Fei is quite a lot. Of course, there are also factors such as age and information. As far as the northern expedition is concerned, Guan Yu hasn't hit Xiangyang yet; Yue Fei's report card in the Northern Expedition is much better. He not only recovered six countries near Xiangyang, but also recovered Luoyang near Shaoxing every six years. Ten years later, Shaoxing is closer to Fengfeng. But judging from the enemy's reaction, Guan Yu had a greater influence on the Northern Expedition.
Guan Yu surrounded Xiangyang and was defeated by the imperial army. Cao Cao dared not move the capital, but fortunately he was persuaded by Sima Yi and Jiang Ji. The evaluation of the three countries is "lofty China".
After recovering Yingchang, Yue Fei wrote to the imperial court, saying that Nuzhen had suffered many defeats and wars, and Jin Wushu asked the first and last child to cross the river first. Is this caused by Yue Fei's unilateral military power?
Similarly, almost at the same time as Yue Jiajun's Northern Expedition, Liu Kun, a famous Southern Song Dynasty star, defeated Jin Wushu in Shunchang. Jurchen generals believe that this is the biggest defeat in fifteen years since the Song War.
Hong Hao, the special envoy of the Southern Song Dynasty who was detained in Yanjing at that time, wrote a secret letter to the Southern Song Dynasty, saying: Jurchen was scared out of her wits by Shunchang's failure and sent all the treasures of Yanjing back to the northeast, ready to give up the area south of Yanjing. It can be seen that the deterrent force against the nomads from the Southern Song Dynasty is composed of many famous soldiers from the Southern Song Dynasty.
At present, there are no specific figures showing how many Guan Yu in Cao Jun are trapped in Xiangyang. But with the ban brought by Xiangyang Town and the "Seven Armies", the number will not be small. Otherwise Cao Cao is not afraid of moving the capital.
Yue Fei Shaoxing ten years northern expedition, the most intense battle took place in Yingchang city. Wang Gui, Dong Xian and Yue Yun led thirty thousand people to guard the city. They fought all day and killed more than 500 enemy soldiers. This is what Wang Gui himself said in The Year of Good News. Prior to this, Yang Zaixing led a patrol of 300 people to encounter nomads in China and annihilated 2,000 enemy troops. The credibility of these figures is questionable, but compared with the nomadic people of "30,000" and "120,000", it does not seem to be very large. Guan Yu's Northern Expedition was more intimidating, which was of course related to the enemy's geographical position. The capital chosen by Emperor Cao Cao and Emperor Han is Xuchang, not far from Xiangyang. The capital of Xu Jinguo is in Huanglongfu, and Yue Fei will not move the capital even if he hits Hebei.
[/s2/] Article 6: Yue has no concubine, so it is difficult to prove it.
According to Ji Shu, Guan Yu took a fancy to the wife of Qin Luyi, the messenger of Lu Bu. When Cao Cao and Liu Bei surrounded Lu Bu, he greeted Cao Cao first. Guan Yu saw that the city was about to be breached and told Cao Cao several times. Cao Cao felt strange and thought, is that woman really that beautiful? I took it and looked at it first. It's really good, just me, which makes Guan Yu very depressed. Whether this anecdote is reliable or not, it is hard to say that Chen Shou's Romance of the Three Kingdoms has no income. The movie "Guan Yunchang" is very popular, and the new relationship between uncle and sister-in-law is really boring and vicious, which is so insulting to Guan Gong. Heroes are not afraid of lewdness, can saints incest?
Yue Fei is not a concubine at home. Wu Jun from Sichuan sent one, and Yue Fei said to the woman through the screen, "You can stay if you want." . The other party didn't speak, just giggled. I guess I'm laughing at Yue Fei for being such a big official and living for a few more days. Yue Fei discovered that something was wrong with her. She sent her back without even meeting her.
Yue Fei is not romantic, Yue Jiajun is disciplined, and men dare not estimate.
However, General Yue Jiajun's family is quite romantic. As soon as the army comes back, a minister named He will report his wife's adultery with a monk. This matter was actually investigated by Yue Fei himself, so it is impossible to find out. According to the confession of the parties, in the temple where the monk is located, almost everyone has a lover, and all the lovers are Yue Fei's family. Yue Fei was afraid of shaking the morale of the army, so he consulted a person. He only punished the first two people who were reported, and everyone else let him go.