Seal: collection, appreciation seal, collection
It should be the inscription on the back of Huai Su's Lun Shu Tie, with the signature of Xiang (1525- 1590) and No.,alias Ren Shan, lay man, Xiang Yan lay man, master tuimian, master tuimizhai, Huiquan Qiao Shan and Moline Nencuo. Guo Mingzisheng, a descendant of Xiang Zhong, was a famous collector and connoisseur in Ming Dynasty.