Before Emperor Qianlong awarded Lu You an award, the famous poetry critics in the early Qing Dynasty generally didn't evaluate Lu You's poems highly. For example, Ye Xie said that "Lu You's excellent works are much more solid, and those who are boring are twice as good" (original poem). Zhu Yizun said, "The Story of Jian Nan written by Lu Wu Guan is thick in syntax, and it is annoying to read it in the end" (after the Story of Jian Nan). He also said: "I think the military attache Lu is too embarrassed" (preface to the poems of Oak Village). He Shang said: "Generally speaking, only a few, not far from the artistic conception. He is only good at writing the scene in front of him, and the syllables can be heard "("Jiuyuan Poetry "). -Talent, poetry and syntax were all moved. Even in the Qianlong period, Lu You's poetic title rose sharply, and Hong and others also sharply criticized Lu You's shoddy and greedy work. They think that the writing speed of Lu You's "ten thousand poems in sixty years" has "delayed many future generations". Shen Deqian affirmed Lu You's seven laws: "Let go of the seven-character law, so that the team can play neatly and things can stick to each other. At that time, nothing was like ",but he also bluntly pointed out:" In eight sentences, you don't accept it up and down ",so you can't" say poetry ". That is to say, the first-class product rate is less than 20% to 30%. According to reports, the Qing people paid great attention to the skill of Lu You's Seven Laws, and few people paid serious attention to it except Liu Kezhuang's "good duality" in the Song Dynasty. Shen Deqian's contemporaries, Chen Xu and Shu Wei, praised Lu You's Seven Laws more clearly. Chen Xu's Selected Poems of Jian Nan: "Weng Fang devoted himself to the Seven Laws all his life, so the complete works contain its essence at most." Shu Wei has the highest evaluation of Lu You's Seven Laws. In "Poems on a Bottle of Water", he praised Lu You for "taking it as a body and collecting its merits", which was regarded as the third milestone in the development history of the Seven Laws (Du Fu and Li Shangyin). This argument has great influence.
Although Lu You can't say that he has devoted his life to the Seven Laws, his seven laws are indeed numerous, with a wide range of contents and themes and different styles. His masterpieces, such as Book Fury and Sleeping in the Water Village, are full of patriotic enthusiasm and determined to recover. Spring rain, illness, etc. in Lin 'an. Are expressions of personal life experiences. A visit to Shanxi village and rural life in early summer describe the leisure life in the countryside. The styles and themes are quite different, but they are all the top grades of Lu You's Seven Laws, which have been circulated for hundreds of years. However, there are not many such works in the whole "Jian Nan Poetry Draft". His seven laws have the idea of learning from Lao Du, but they tend to be fresh and exquisite, mature and ingenious, but they are not as good as refining, flowing and sinking. Generally speaking, Lu You's metrical poems (mainly seven-meter poems) have many good sentences, but few good ones. Pan Deyu, a Qing Dynasty man, said that his "seven-tone poems", Zhao Yi's Poems of Oubei, Zhang Peiren's Poems of Miaoxiang, Chen Yan's Poems of One Poetry and Jiannan's poems were all extracted from Lu You's poems in order to try to figure out. Some of them are really pure gold and beautiful jade, and people can't put it down. Such as heavy male police pull, state sad: